Jeff discovers that an old girlfriend still loves him even after that he sets out to prove to Audrey that she never was in love with him to begin with. Timmy decides to quit after learning he has been tracked by Russell put a chip in to Timmy.
Adam thinks he will get a surprise party but Jennifer makes sure it will happen after it wasn’t going to happen. Jennifer paints a mural for Audrey & Jeff that is quite different.
Audrey and Jeff decide to join take a cooking class that Jennifer and Adam are currently taking, but it becomes a problem after Jennifer makes an unkind to remark of up to about her cooking. Timmy has a problem with the Russell's new girlfriend.
Jeff tries to see if he and Audrey can possibly sneak into there favorite restaurant hoping they can overlook that Jeff neglected to make a reservation.
Jeff and Audrey visit old friends in Syracuse for the weekend, expecting to party. Adam spends a lot of time with his bird, trying to teach it a trick and annoying Jennifer. Timmy tricks Russell into volunteering at a nursing home.
Liz wants to have baby but who she asks for help may shock Jeff and Audrey. Jeff coaches Timmy to take an unusual step to date a co-worker. Adam fumbles a special delivery that Jen has been expecting.
Liz causes problems with Audrey and Jeff when Audrey has trouble getting Jeff to agree with her. Adam and Timmy have a ping pong match to see how good or bad the rest of the gang is.