After a long night of frights and screams, the Blue team was successful in gathering the final clues behind the mystery. Sally attended Camp Silver Lake originally as a camper, and would annually attend every summer. It is here where she met a fellow counselor named Sam, where they fell in love, and eventually became engaged. One day, Sally was blamed for an accident, and was demoted to kitchen duty for the remainder of camp. While preparing one of the meals, she accidentally cut off her hand. Not able to retrieve the hand, she had it replaced with a hook. Falling into a state of depression, she was too embarrassed to marry Sam. Despite many pleas from Sam to continue on with the wedding, Sam was left at the chapel doors, while Sally disappeared, never to be seen again.