J.D. wakes up the morning after an incredibly awful blowout between all the characters, hoping it was all a dream. Turk is sleeping next to him since Carla kicked him out of his own room for not telling her about how Dr Cox felt about her. On their way to work, J.D. and Turk pass a musician who starts following J.D. around the hospital singing a very coincidental song. They pass Dr. Cox, who is ashamed with Carla, mad at Dr. Kelso, for misleading him about a job offer, and furious with J.D. for sleeping with his ex-wife. They also pass Elliot who quickly leaves, ashamed to be seen by J.D. now that he knows she still has feelings for him.
After Dr. Cox unleashes his anger on Dr Kelso, he proceeds to be surprisingly polite to J.D. Meanwhile, Turk is trying to get back on Carla's good side but is confused when he realises he doesn't know why she is mad at him. Elliot and J.D. have an awkward conversation where J.D. suggests they sleep with each other, giving a reason for Elliot to be mad at him.
When J.D. realises that Dr Cox isn't yelling at him because he doesn't care about him anymore, he pages everyone to the cafeteria, where everyone argues and nothing is resolved.
J.D. later realises he's late for rounds and hasn't done any tests or medication for a patient yet. When Dr. Kelso confronts him on this, J.D. is honest and said he did nothing, to which Dr. Kelso compliments him as good doctors know that any patient bounced from ward to ward has a high risk of fever. Shocked at this response, J.D. realises that doing nothing sometimes works and all people need is time.
Eventually, J.D. and Elliot are comfortable to be around each other again, Dr Cox realises he just idealises Carla, Carla lets Turk back into his own room and Dr Cox starts yelling and caring about J.D. again, putting everything back to normal.
Throughout this episode, the Janitor is back to his usual tricks and repeatedly sprays J.D. so it looks like he wet his pants, causing J.D. to go through quite a few pairs of pants.