Dare To Be Honest
Written by Bruce Eric Kaplan
Directed by Peter Webber
8.0
With their snogging session at the end of "Terror Starts At Home", it appears that Nate and Brenda are having an affair on the sly, booking into rather seedy looking motels and lying about taking Maya to daycare to steal a few private moments with each other and while you would normally be pleased to see the pair back together, it's made abundantly clear that they are with each other for the wrong reasons.
Nate even concedes that himself when he insists that Brenda should try and work things out with Joe after a visit from Lisa, who encourages him to forget his former girlfriend in favour for pursuing a former co-worker from the kennels, although it is hard to figure whether Lisa's advice was genuinely meant to be unhelpful or not, but either way, her appearance on this episode does keep faithful with her character and I always knew that we'd see her in this capacity for Nate, assumng the sort of role Nathaniel had for the eldest Fisher in the earlier seasons of the show and while it won't make her endearing to those who couldn't stand her when she was alive, at least it won't make you dislike her any further too.
However, getting back to Nate and Brenda before they decided to break off their unwise fling, the latter's all too documented fear of commitment is constantly prodded at with Nate comparing himself to Joe (hey, remember you also weren't Mr Faithful while you and Bren were together even if it was only Lisa you slept with and impregnated) and with Brenda unable to escape the fact, she decides to tell Joe but leaves out who the mystery man is/was. Not that it matters, Joe is probably articulate enough to hazard a guess. His reaction of indifference though is a tad baffling. I had hoped for some shouting and fireworks but the lack of such is fortunately compensated by his touch and go indecision of whether to take her back or not. Even if he does, it's fair to assume that this is the beginning of the end for the pair, which is a bit of a shame because although some people may beg to differ Brenda and Joe were actually a lot more preferable compared to some of the couplings we've had this season. Especially a recent marriage that is cracking ...
You'd think that over the past couple of weeks of learning more about your new husband's checkered past and putting up with his childish behaviour that that would be enough in terms of fossil hunting for Ruth. But when her and George do it for real in Topanga, he still manages to grate on your nerves just that extra bit more, especially during their visit at Sarah and Bettina's when he ignores all three women in favour for the TV.
Thank God for Sarah and Bettina. After what it seemed like ages, the pair are finally back and as wonderful as ever and it's high time Ruth had people to talk and it was nice to see her and Sarah on more pleasant terms with each other for a change too. Sarah was actually more intriguing than bettina here, due to seemingly new found stability and rather perceptive comparisons to both Nathaniel and George finally seemed to drop the penny for Ruth (or close enough to it) regarding surly Sibley's beastly behaviour just of late and hopefully this is enough to force Ruth to snap him out of it for the audiences sake as well as hers.
Meanwhile David's desperate attempts of coping with life post attack continue to crumble as I had expected. Last week's episode of him keeping things in order was hardly a successful feat when he got a panic attack and here he further fails miserably when he tells Claire he doesn't need her staying with him and unwisely wanting to have sex with a bartender in an ill-conceived stab of numbing his feelings of helplessness. Thankfully, all these setbacks do force him to face up to his anxiety as well as telling Keith that he doesn't want to continue with the open relationships in a scene that will have fans sighing with relief.
As does Keith finally fessing up to his sexuality in which Celeste informs him that Javier (the bodyguard who put the word out about Keith beforehand) is also gay and for the first time the sixteen year old mini-brat shows a spark of likeability, although her sudden sweetness does hold some suspicions. And while i'm glad that Keith is finally out, it's only when he tells David about Javier's note of wanting to sleep with him that the open relationship ban comes into play. And while i'm also happy about that it does feel a little one sided and seems to stem more from David's need to be needed right now rather than him and Keith progressing as a couple and let's face it, David is in a bad place at the moment. Still happy about 'No Open Relationship' thing though.
Speaking of bad places, the shit finally hits the fan big time for Federico and while he may have done the right thing at first by ending his non-sexual affair with Sophia, it still wasn't enough to placate Vanessa's understandable rage and her turfing him out of their home and smacking him one, clearly demonstrated showing she's no woman to cheat on, even if it is emotionally. Although I would preferred Sophia to have been on the receiving end of that shiner. Unfortunately, Rico the idiot then cheats on her for real by actually bedding the potential bunny boiler when he has no option but to live with her. There are well above par performances here from both Freddy Rodriguez and Justina Machado, with much praise also for Idalis DeLeon as Sophia further sinks her claws into the hapless Rico.
It's been looming for weeks, with hints dropped rather subtle but obvious at the same time and the build up has been intriguing as Claire's sexy photos of Edie not only earned the praise she deserved this season for anything she's done artistically, but also assumptions from another student that the pair are lovers and before some viewers prattle on about how contrived this plot appears to be, here's why I think the Claire/Edie attraction necessarily isn't. First of all, it was actually Edie who made the first move and keeping in character, Claire initially balked, despite her confused feelings. The build up towards an inevitable sex scene is actually done rather nicely and even Ambrose and Suvari seemed a little more at ease with it than most actors would be. You also have to take into account that Claire didn't confirm whether she was bisexual or not, so as far as i'm concerned and until proven otherwise she's straight. And it wouldn't be the first time we've seen straight characters sleeping with members of the same sex on the show. Both Billy and Russell slept with Olivier (who will sleep with anyone, but that's beside the point). Speaking of Rusty, apparantly him and attention seeking Anita are sleeping with each other. Fantastic, but i'm more interested as to how they'll react about Claire and Edie. I'm betting Russell won't be thrilled but seeing as he did it with Olivier while he was supposed to being in a committed relationship (that phrase almost feels like a character of it's own the more it's used) he won't be one to pass judgement. Anita, on the otherhand I can see blowing a gasket.
Also in "The Dare"
The handling of this week's death - Joan Morrison died off screen of a tumour was probably the most subtlety conveyed for a good while.
David:"Did you hear those two cats having sex in the alley last night?"
Claire:"They were worse than Mom and George".
Federico (to Nate):"I get it. Having to admit fucked shit about yourself fucking sucks".
I'm guessing that shiner really did have to hurt Freddy Rodiguez and Justina Machado looked like she had a lot of fun doing that scene.
Vanessa:"Oh my God. Rico's charity has a Double-D"
Angelica:"I will crush his balls off".
Keith: "Javier, i'm gay. I have a boyfriend okay. I sleep with men and the sex is really, really gay".
Since when did Sarah own a TV? I don't remember seeing one in either Back To The Garden or You Never Know? Patricia Clarkson looked really beautiful in this episode making Sarah's fresh from rehab look even more plausible.
Ruth (re paper monsters):"That one is really hideous"
Sarah:"Oh that's mine".
Grossest moment - Nate fiddling with his condom. Or maybe i'm being oversensitive here.
Celeste (to Keith):"Why didn't you tell me you were gay, bitch?"
Edie:"Claire, what's going on here? I feel like maybe you're into me but you're confused, right? Cos I could be into you if I knew you were into me".
Chronology wise, it's February 2004, so two weeks has passed since "Terror Starts At Home".
Vanessa (to Rico):"I sat outside that house! I saw her face, I saw what the fuck it is you left for her. She loves you!"
Nate:"This is giving me a really bad feeling"
Lisa:"Uh-oh. I'd be careful if I were you. Might be a tumour".
Loved Lisa dressed as a flower and chucking onions at Nate and did anyone else notice "I'm A Lonely Little Petunia In An Onion Patch" (this episode's standout music) being sung by two different artists? Nate has to be the petunia, right?
Initially I wanted to rate this episode really high, down to the reappearances of Sarah and Bettina but this episode is good it was impossible not to like it and the plot threads are really put through the ringer here with some truly sparkling dialogue and character moments as well as the excellent use of camera work here. You definitely won't be bored with this one.