We're moving Forums to the Community pages. Click here for more information and updates.

A Sleepy Hollow Community
Friday 9:00 PM on FOX
This week I came into the episode with my expectations properly adjusted for the type of show Sleepy Hollow intends to be (aka a mix of Supernatural/Grimm). I have plenty to say about where I stand this week, but I think the tenor of some of my recap will let you know how I feel about some of the latest developments so let's begin.

This week we started out with a dream sequence that I truly enjoyed (when was the last time a TV show actually pulled that trope off successfully?)


Abbie walked into the police station with Orlando Jones (whose name I dont think has actually been used beyond calling him Captain - we are 3 episodes in and the 3rd guy in the credits list still hasn't had anyone say his name!)(Another side note - no Katrina this episode - boo). Anyway Abbie walked up to this new character and they watched through the glass as Ichabod interrogated a young Abbie Mills.


Ichabod was interrogating Abbie about seeing the demon in the woods. Old Abbie was not happy about reliving this part of her life and busted in on this interrogation.


White-eyed Ichabod told her to stop lying and then disappeared. Abbie started to freak out about being trapped in the interrogation room. Then the real nightmare appeared:


Abbie definitely seemed a little more freaked out about being trapped in a room than the eyeless sand monster in her dreams if you judged her demeanor upon waking up. Clearly she has been spending too much time with Ichabod.


Abbie was awoken in response to a 911 situation where a woman was threatening to jump off a building and would only talk to Abbie. Abbie went up to talk to the woman, but did not recognize her (however she was the doctor woman from the dream). The doctor said that she knew Jenny wasn't crazy and that she was telling the truth, but she kept her locked up in the insane asylum. She told Abbie that they deserved it for what they did.


Once again the woman had the same white eyes as Ichabod had in Abbie's dream. After telling Abbie that they deserved it, the woman jumped off of the building. Subsequently, her eyes burst into sand when The Crew (let's come up with a good name for Abbie, Ichabod, and Orlando everybody) were examining the body.



In consultation with Orlando Jones Abbie and Ichabod found out that the doctor had treated Jenny when she was first institutionalized. Also, apparently Orlando has definitively staked a claim directly on the Abbie+Ichabod side of the fence.



Then Abbie filled Ichabod in on her "prophetic dream" that included him and the doctor that she had never met before. Ichabod believed that it was another sign that Abbie was a Witness. Once again Abbie was giving Ichabod grief about the whole supernatural side of things (even after we went through this last week as well) and claimed that there wasn't anything out of the ordinary going on.





Abbie and Ichabod returned to the Ichabode or IHH for short (a combination of suggestions from Gislef and zsandmann - thanks!) to watch some old VHS tapes of the doctor talking to Jenny and also shoot the breeze about Abbie's past. Abbie quickly explained the whole situation as completely normal - the doctor felt guilty about locking Jenny up despite believing her and she sought out Abbie for absolution before she killed herself.



Ichabod quickly squashed this theory by reminding Abbie about the exploding sand eyes and then Abbie even pitched in by telling Ichabod about the doctor's exclamation that "they" deserved it. Ichabod made the clear jump in logic that someone sent the sandman to attack that someone's enemies (Abbie). Ichabod then decided that they should go see Jenny - much to Abbie's chagrin.




Abbie was convinced that Jenny wouldn't help them because Abbie was a cop and Jenny was a criminal. Hey everybody just to reiterate from the picture above - ABBIE ROBBED A PHARMACY - so no total hypocrisy to see here. Apparently Jenny had stolen $4000 worth of survival gear because the End of Days were coming (seems pretty rational and actually is happening to me) making her completely unclean in Abbie's eyes. In fact Abbie hadnt seen her sister in five years since she had been sent back to the mental hospital. Her prediction turned out to be accurate as Jenny refused to see her, but then Ichabod stepped up to the plate.


Naturally Jenny let Ichabod in to talk to her. They actually had a pretty nice repartee going for a bit and Jenny even assigned him a nickname.


Then Ichabod dropped a bomb on Jenny and told her that he knew about the demon in the woods and that the horsemen had started to return. He also informed her of the death of her former psychiatrist. Jenny was a little bit shaken and I fell straight into it - I am onboard:


Ichabod asked for Jenny's help with the dream demon. Not only could Jenny not help them with their current problem (she had a clear conscience - we'll get back to that), but she told Ichabod that they had no chance against the oncoming army - that it was all over, but the crying. At the end she threw a little bit of shade at Abbie, telling Ichabod to ask her about it.



Apparently when Abbie and Jenny ran into the demon in the woods they had disappeared for four days until they were discovered by a small town hero.



When Jenny and Abbie were interrogated by the police about their disappearance Abbie told Jenny to stay quiet and not say anything about the demon.


Unfortunately for Jenny she decided to tell the truth to the police while Abbie looked on silently and refused to back up anything that Jenny was saying.


The man that found the two girls had also seen the demon and likewise had not said anything about it. So while Abbie got to go home to her family, Jenny got hauled off to the mental hospital.


Abbie and Ichabod then headed off to talk to the man who found the missing girls who was himself not having a great day. However, before we get to that lets get into the back story for Orlando Jones a little bit more. We were given a short scene where Orlando Jones is being pranked by the office douchebag (Abbie's ex) which let us know that apparently Orlando Jones is not only in charge, but that he is also brand spanking new in town - oh and that we should assume that he knows everything.



Ichabod, Abbie, and Orlando then arrived separately at the Hero's house where the Hero was having a not very good day courtesy of the sandman. The Hero informed Abbie that she was next and that when she went to sleep next she would die. He then killed himself. Abbie and Ichabod then put together the pieces about the Sandman's identity as Ichabod remembered a story told to him once by his Mohawk friends about a demon named Roko for short (I have no idea what that things whole name was, I swear Ichabod said it differently in various scenes).


Despite sarcastically asking about an Encyclopedia of Faceless Nightmare Monsters earlier in the episode it turned out that one actually existed in the IHH. Also in case you were wondering I believe Abbie's energy drink was called Extended Wake - so go out and buy yourself some today! Abbie and Ichabod eventually decided that they needed the assistance of a Mohawk shaman to stop the sandman so they went to Geronimotors (the actual name in the show) to see a man named:




In case you can't make out the nametag, our friend here is named Seamus Duncan. It turns out that luckily enough he could help out our heroes after all once he became concerned about having a clear conscience. He had Abbie drink some liquid that he already had prepared (and there was a lot of it for some strange reason).



Ichabod couldn't let Abbie go into the dreamworld to face the Sandman alone (since she could die for real there) and came along for the ride. The next step before they could enter the dream world was for our heroes to be stung by scorpions, but all I could think was:


Abbie really needs to introduce Ichabod to McDonalds. Once in the dreamworld Abbie was quickly taken by the Sandman and forced to rewatch her interrogation sequence again. Meanwhile Ichabod should have been taking notes from Being Human:




The Sandman wanted to know one very important thing:


Here is where I had to take issue with this episode. Earlier in episode 1 Abbie told Ichabod the truth that she had seen the demon and we also know that Corbin knew the truth - so is the purpose of the demon here to make Abbie admit to herself that she said nothing out of self interest? I mean I would understand if the demon could only be appeased by Abbie getting Jenny set free or by Abbie admitting to the appropriate authorities that she had seen the demon in order to set Jenny free, but this made no sense to me. How does Abbie admitting that she had seen the demon (which she has already done) in the dreamworld (to no one new) change anything, especially since (I hope at least) she already felt guilty about what she did to Jenny. Hasn't the demon here only really been punishing 3 people who left an innocent teenage girl in a mental institution for more than 10 years? Is he really that "evil"? Not exactly the baddie I would expect from the demon army sent to start the End of Days.

I was however, kind of intrigued by this potential development:


What sins? Who gets to punish Ichabod? Food for thought. Anyway after Abbie admitted to no one new that she had in fact seen the demons she easily dispatched the Sandman.


Back in the IHH, Orlando found our two heroes someplace that they were not supposed to be.


He was essentially like no problem, Ill give you a key. Ichabod then asked if Orlando wanted to hear about their adventures, but Orlando wanted none of that (maybe because he's not allowed to interfere).


At the end of the episode Abbie decided to go talk to her innocent, completely sane sister who she had treated like a deranged delinquent leper for the better part of 10 years. She seemed pretty confident that she could get her sister to forgive her.


However, Jenny had made her escape.


And Abbie immediately reverted to forgetting that Jenny was completely innocent and totally sane.




I'm still not completely sure where I stand on this show, but I am having a lot of fun photo recapping it each week. Please let me know what you think in the comments and if you have anything you'd like me to focus more/less on.

Jenny totally knew about the Sandman with her clear conscience line right?

When will we see Jenny again?

Are you Team Jenny or Team Abbie?

Was the Sandman really that evil?

How do you feel about Abbie after this week's episode?


You can also check out my previous photo recaps:

The 100 Trailer
Revolution Episode 201

Sleepy Hollow Trailer
Sleepy Hollow Episode 101
Sleepy Hollow Episode 102
31 Comments
Comments (25)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
It wasn't just Abbie's betrayal of Jenny that the Sandman was punishing, it was Abbie's insistence on acting alone, on feeling alone. Roky... (for short) was like a predator, picking off single members of a herd: isolate them, manipulate them, then destroy them. Notice the point in the episode where Abbie fights back against the demon: when he is about to attack Crane. It is the demon's attack against Crane that causes Abbie to find the courage to confront the demon. It wasn't just Abbie turning her back on Jenny or the truth that gave Roky power, it was about Abbie denying that she was a part of a tribe, that she had to do it alone.

It explains why Crane HAD to follow her into the dream. The distance between her and her sister wouldn't have given Abbie enough strength to survive the battle. Her sister was upset at her for her betrayal, she felt guilt at not admitting the truth, there was a gap the size of a Grand Canyon between them. But with Crane, seeing him in danger, accepting that bond between them, made her fight for her tribe. With Crane in danger, not only was she not running away, she was admitting the truth, a truth inexorably tied up with Crane.

If anything, Crane's many headlong dashes into danger for her (at the Gillespie house, before the dream fight) is sort of the proof she's needed that she isn't alone. Her looking up and seeing him through the window at the Gillespie house, a throwaway scene, becomes part of the continuity, part of her growing list of evidence that Ichabod, for all his complications and issues, really is there for her. And not just in the comforting, friend sort of way. If we are to think of the metaphors of the horsemen, and the puppetmaster behind them, we can think of them collectively as Despair, lack of hope, lack of reason to live. Therefore, it only makes sense that the two Witnesses called to do battle with those said forces must not only bring their physical powers into play but their emotional, even spiritual powers as well. And what great emotional and spiritual power is there....besides love. I do not think Katrina's imprisonment is an accident. If the demon thought to diminish Ichabod's powers by depriving him of his 'love,' what greater surprise would await him than to find out...he imprisoned the wrong person. Those shipping the Ichabbie thread...I would say the evidence is outstanding. Of course, admitting their love will probably be the final act of their tribulation. Only at the edge of failure, at the threat of seperation, will they find the power in each other to defeat the agents of Despair. Like Ichabbie, the fans will, at some point, have to fight the agents of despair in order to keep the show alive to its conclusion. Tv needs more happy, satisfying endings. This show promises to add to that list.

Ichabbie Now, Ichabbie Forever.
More+
2
Reply
Flag
team jenny, haha. :)
I did think the solution was way too simple, but I've decided to go along with the show and see where it's taking me.

Okay, just a request for future photo recaps, could you cut down on the use of acronyms? Please? :)
Reply
Flag
haha, or never mind, I'll just google what I don't understand.

Reply
Flag
I'm team Icky/Abby/Jenny. I doubt that they will be opposing each other.
3
Reply
Flag
like the (re) caps! this show is growing on me.
1
Reply
Flag
slow clap...I love the photo recaps.
1
Reply
Flag
What I really liked about the confrontation between Abbie and the Sandman is that, for the first time, she actually fess up to a supernatural creature.

It's one thing to admit things to Ichabod, the Captain or Sheriff Corbin because these men fall into the realm of what Abbie considers is real, but to actually step up and interact with a monster? There's no turning back from it.

She willingly crosses a line she wasn't ready to cross three episodes ago. And that put her in the same league as Jenny.
2
Reply
Flag
Who isn't Team Jenny? She's doing her end of the world type fitness program in an insane asylum just like Linda Hamiltion in T2 "How's the hand Doctor?"

I liked Abbie's confession/confrontation with the sandman in the face of her fear, kind of like turning the light of in the bathroom, looking in the mirror and saying "Candyman" 3 times before he shows up behind you and cuts your throat.

Yep he was evil, why else the ridiculously long fingers? All the better to snatch your soul with my dear! I mean they consider that girl from the well in Ring or Ring-o to be evil or malicious, really she was just a chain letter you pass on to the next sucker, so Rokowhatevertyes shouldn't get a pass as just some kind of spiritual Jiminy Cricket.
8
Reply
Flag
According to IMDb Orlando Jones plays Captain Frank Irving ;)
5
Reply
Flag
As in Washington IRVING?! Love it!!!
1
Reply
Flag
I'm calling him The Captain and promise not to use his full name until we figure out which side he's on.
3
Reply
Flag
I was really enjoying the episode up until abbie had to tell the demon that she saw him. It felt really juvenile, and a little corny? Reading through the comments and the recap, I get why she needed to say it, but watching the scene play out made me think it was kind of dumb.

Otherwise, I'm still liking the show so far. I think it's perfect for the fall/halloween time.
Reply
Flag
" I mean I would understand if the demon could only be appeased by Abbie getting Jenny set free or by Abbie admitting to the appropriate authorities that she had seen the demon in order to set Jenny free, but this made no sense to me. How does Abbie admitting that she had seen the demon (which she has already done) in the dreamworld (to no one new) change anything, especially since (I hope at least) she already felt guilty about what she did to Jenny."

I don't think her doing it normally in her dream would have made any good. However, as Seamus noted, they were in the Sandman's dreamscape and could control their actions because of the scorpion venom. Seamus (Seamus the Shaman?) also said that he couldn't tell her what challenge she would face.

So in this case, Abbie was able to manipulate the dreamscape by acknowledging her guilt and overcoming her fear, and using it as a weapon to defeat the Sandman on his own ground. But if he had come after her in her dream, without the prep, she would have been driven to suicide.

5
Reply
Flag
"I have no idea what that things whole name was, I swear Ichabod said it differently in various scenes."

According to the closed captioning, Ro'kenhrontyes
Reply
Flag
It's in the episode recap on the episode page... Sometimes I wonder if it's better to post the recaps here then there.
Reply
Flag
Can someone remind me which other show Jenny plays at... i knew her but can't remember where
2
Reply
Flag
oh now I remember ''NIKITA''
1
Reply
Flag
She reminds me of jasmine guy and a young eartha kitt too but yeah she's the techie from Nikita
3
Reply
Flag
I thought I was the only one who thought of Jasmine Guy when I saw her! Lol they do look like they could be related (0even googled a picture of Guy from her days on A Different World)!
2
Reply
Flag
Hahah that's nothing, when i saw the promo and the firs time I heard her talk it threw me that she didn't sound like Whitney from a different world. Still I think she's the perfect actress to play Jennie.
1
Flag
  1. I have no idea if Jenny knew, but as Seamus there claimed the same line, I wonder if it is some sort of supernatural influence. Like Roko was following his subjects before visiting them and when anyone else was challenged, that was the line he says through them.
  2. Next week apparently, it sort of looks like she kidnaps some member of the dark coven (there goes my theory the priest was doing a rocking job of keeping Sleepy Hollow clear of bad guys except John Cho) and then either lures or kidnaps Ichabod to somewhere to get him to help her.
  3. Well, I totally understood Abby's point (the whole foster family thing we are apparently going to get into, I appreciate a sense of self preservation, though I think I might have played the whole I saw something but I don't really know what it was but I don't think it was just a hunter or something, but whoever it was scared me a lot), and you kind of felt for Jenny...I sort of sense there is more to Jenny that might make us more Team Abby down the road...like she might have caused problems that got them kicked out of other foster homes, I'm guessing we hear the pharmacy robbery was ultimately to help Jenny, and it sounded like five years ago, Abby tried to specifically help her, but I am guessing you make one mistake with Jenny and she is done.
  4. Probably not...but I have a feeling there will be a few of these people along the way. I am hoping for a discovery down the road (and Ichabod's voiceover at the beginning implies this) that there are good and neutral supernatural forces who are also clearing decks. Like Orlando (who in the show, his last name is Irving, I don't know what his first name is). As I do believe this is some sort of Supernatural/Grimm combo show, I think we are going to have creatures like this, probably some angels, reapers, if we are right and the HH is not Death, Death, fates, etcetera, who might just be personifications of forces of nature.
  5. It seemed really quick and I am not sure if that was because it followed the same sort of formula that was in last week or Fox just inundates it with commercials. I do kind of think that the admission that Abby had to make was that she made the decision out of cowardice and not rationalize it like she did when she explained it to Ichabod. Its one thing to admit actions, but you have to admit why and be remorseful.
Hey, randomly...do we think it is Abby or Abbie?
I missed Katia too..why do I think there is going to be something that happens that she and Jenny accidentally change places and we have more grander mythology because everyone knows Katia can at least protect herself there.
More+
2
Reply
Flag
I'm team Mills all the way! No, not Regina (OUAT), but the actual Mills sisters that actually act like foster kids that actually grew up in the system (and have actual issues because of what they believe).

I don't know what to think. Sometimes it feels like the witnesses are Jenny and Abbie (and Ichabod something like Andy Dunn), sometimes that is Ichabod and Abbie and sometimes, like in this epi, that is Jenny and Ichabod.
7
Reply
Flag
Great recap! :-D
Love the Icky shots but don't forget Abbie ;-)
I didn't find the monster that scary either...
Mmm I haven't picked a team yet LOL

3
Reply
Flag
great recap. While Abbie admitted to Ichabod what she saw, she felt like she was in the right. They had a foster family and she felt that not saying anything was better. In the dream her confession had more to do with what she did to Jenny then anything. I don't think the sandman is evil necessarily. Think about the incarnations of death. while spooky, death has no agenda- it just is. So i think if anything the sandman (not even going to try to say the native american name) is essentially guilt. If you have a clear conscience, you have nothing to worry about, if you don't you're guilt could literally kill you. I think Jenny knows about all the demons because she embraced the truth and now is probably psychic of sorts. Leaning towards team jenny, she doesn't have douchebag ex. :) You missed the Ichabod tries an energy drink for the first time screen shot. I think if anything you need to have the obligatory, ichabod gets used to the 21st century bits.
4
Reply
Flag
Follow this Show
Members
13,014