The Mills sisters are headed for some quality time together, until the Sandman strikes everyone who ever believed in Jenny. For the triumph of evil entails good men to do nothing, her shrink, her friends and her sister are systematically targeted for turning their back on her.
As the foster kids they really are, each sister refuses to rely on another. Jenny escapes from the mental hospital hoping to lure the demon after her, and Abbie embarks on a trip of her own thanks to a shaman with a daytime job. Ichabod may not know which sister his fate is entwined with - he may not be a witness to begin with - but he chooses Abbie and sticks to her until they both wake up from the ordeal. When Lt. Mills finally steps into the room of the truest believer, Miss Mills is already gone.