The effects of Brainiac on Chloe's mind grow. Clark makes a desperate trip to the Arctic to get help from Jor-El. Davis begins pushing for a relationship with Chloe even as she loses her knowledge of Clark's secret.moreless
8.5
"Great"
This episode is one big surprise - so different from most Smallville stories. It has only one plot - no subplots, no issue of constant switching from one story line to another. The cast is limited to only four main characters - Clark, Chloe, Jimmy, and Davis - and Jor-El, if you count a disembodied voice. The script is therefore necessarily sparse, confined to only one idea.
It's been some time coming. Chloe is finally experiencing the shattering effects of the actions of Brainiac on her mind. I found the concept for showing how she begins to lose her memory to be imaginative and effective. A background of flashes of scenes from her life surround her. A kryptonian symbol also appears to her, and when she sketches it, Clark identifies it as the symbol for "Doom." In her mind's eye, objects such as furniture begin to disappear. This may not be valid psychologically, but it sure works visually.
"Abyss" is all about Chloe, and Ms. Mack does her usual fine acting job - we wouldn't expect anything less. Jimmy is the first to notice how rapidly she is losing her grip on reality, even as they approach their wedding date. Clark sees the signs too, as Chloe finally describes to him how she's just barely holding things together - in the ISIS tech room, she has covered the walls with photos and documents related to her life - a pathological obsession with keeping things together, but it won't work for long. He pulls out the blue crystal, determined to ask for help from Jor-El, against Chloe's plea to avoid the risk of another trip to the Phantom Zone.
Clark winds up in the Arctic again, and Jor-El is unusually supportive of Clark and the struggles he has had and the decisions he has made. But there is a risk to Chloe in restoring her memory.
When Davis comes to the Talon apartment to offer support, Jimmy is just too accommodating. His benign reaction is unlike Jimmy's usual jealousy of anyone near Chloe, but here he seems clueless.
Clark brings the unconscious Chloe to the Fortress, and when the memory restoration begins, her eyes turn black, and a black fluid drains from her ear - presumably a deposit made by Brainiac. This seems tantamount to removing a contaminant, but the writers make this result in her forgetting Clark's secret, an awfully selective memory loss.
The Smallville writers and producers can and have reversed the course of previous storylines. Offenses are forgotten, murders forgiven, prosecutions overlooked, hurts and resentments glossed over. But Clark's loss of his valuable ally, confidant, protector, hacker, and interference-runner is significant. She is still his friend, but I can't see the writers coming up with a re-set button to return to the Chloe of the past several seasons - learning his secret all over again would seem so like a Season 4 redux. Yet how can they go forward from here? Is this to be seen as a necessary step in developing the Superman character? Must he become an independent force by cutting ties to a mortal, even one who has been so instrumental in his development? Is this the ultimate act of friendship by Clark - to accept this extreme loss for the sake of protecting Chloe?
With Chloe's marriage coming up, the story arc would result in an inevitable change in the Clark-Chloe relationship - domestic affairs would become her main concern - a commitment to Jimmy and their new life limiting her ability to drop everything to support Clark and his endeavors. So anxiety is piling up on me, wondering if we're losing Chloe, or even if she's on her way out of the series. It's a common assumption that she's under contract for all of Season 8, so that should not happen, and Ms. Mack is even progged to direct an upcoming episode. Frankly, I'd just as soon see that re-set button pushed, but not instantaneously - take a few episodes for her restoration - let it make some sense and require effort. Think of all the enjoyment we've had from Chloe's collaboration with Clark - humor, joy, tragedy, frustration, excitement, anxiety, triumph. Can Lois begin to take on this role?
By the end of "Abyss," most all relationships are back to normal and the wedding is on. But Davis gets pushy, telling Chloe flatly that Jimmy is not right for her, and that when she had lost almost everything, she came to him for help. He puts just enough back in her mind to create doubt about her love for Jimmy. Of course, the Doomsday storyline approaches, and Davis does not yet fully realize what he is - only clues from the Lois/Faora encounter last week. But his worldly attraction to Chloe means she'll be right in the line of fire from whatever comes out of Davis in the next few episodes. So her loss of knowledge of Clark's secret is not enough to protect her from another adversary. Despite Clark's best efforts, he's going to have to save her again.
Like I said, it's a surprise to see such a limited scope for a Smallville story - the producers obviously meant to move ahead rapidly with the Davis/Doomsday threat by dropping any distracting side issues. Against the implications for Chloe and her part in Smallville, even the Clark - Lois relationship seems diminished in importance - until this is resolved. And until then I'm in mourning over the loss of a key character and all the enjoyment that has come from the special Clark-Chloe friendship. Re-run rating - an angst-ridden B.moreless