Lana's childhood friend, who died accidently six years earlier, suddenly reappears, leading Lana to believe she's seeing a ghost. But Lionel is involved, and Clark sees her too, leading to his discovery of another Luthorcorp scheme.moreless
8.5
"Great"
After the gang watches a '50s horror flick at the Talon, Lana cleans up the theatre alone, when someone flips on home movies of her childhood, and slams the door. Then her small childhood friend Emily, who died young, appears to her in several places, and Lana panics, until Clark steps in. So what's real and what isn't? It may be one of those episodes where everything is a dream, or a meteor-rock-induced hallucination.
Later at home, Lana gets another jolt when little Emily appears again, claiming to be real. Clark is there again, Emily vanishes, and Lana takes Clark to the Elbow River Bridge, where she tells him the story - Emily slipped off the bridge and drowned but Lana could not help her. The musical score should be noted here - it's very wistful and a perfect match for this scene, as good as any Hitchcock movie - perhaps reminiscent of "Vertigo." Clark suggests visiting Emily's father, Pete Dinsmore (Neil Flynn) in Granville, who turns out to be distant and unsympathetic to Lana's claim to have seen his daughter, and he has never fully recovered from his loss.
Side story is an update on Lex and Helen's wedding plans, with Lionel still insisting that his cash offer to Helen to leave Lex was doing him a favor - by verifying her loyalty. No wedding invitation for Lionel, but he presents a gift - a paid honeymoon trip via Luthorcorp jet. But these two have such a history of distrust that Lex can never accept anything at face value - and it's often true that ulterior motives exist within both of them.
Chloe and Clark continue their mild hostility while Clark scans the Net to help Lana. Her interest piqued, Chloe theorizes that Lana's stress is causing hallucinations. The newspaper archive about Emily's drowning mentions the Elbow River bridge in 1996, and Lana's presence during the accident. At Mr. Dinsmore's house, we're shocked to see Emily, or an apparition of her, fully visible to her father. She is a defiant little girl and won't allow herself to be locked up. As Dinsmore attempts to grab her, she disappears, and suddenly, a spear-like pole flies across the yard and spears Dinsmore like a marshmallow at a campfire. Surely he's dead.
The silly scene of the episode has Clark and Pete in a cemetery in a pouring rain, with street clothes only. So Directors think that a soaking wet star is more dramatic than one with the smarts to take an umbrella? They find Emily's grave, and Clark x-rays a corpse therein, so someone died sometime. But Emily then appears nearby - for no logical reason, but she can move at superspeed. In some nifty special effects, Clark chases her through near-stationary raindrops, but the little kid beats even him. However, he finds her necklace.
Back at the Talon, Emily appears to Lana again, terrorizing her, but disappearing again when Clark arrives, reassuring Lana that he, too, saw Emily. Lana recognizes the necklace as Emily's.
Lionel is at the hospital visiting a former employee, when Lex checks in on him, suspicious of Lionel's every move, which Lionel again pegs as paranoia. The employee turns out to be Mr. Dinsmore, recovering from the spear wound, apparently inflicted by Emily. Then Lex, too, sees Emily, who says Lionel is a bad man who took away the bunnies in her back yard. Now how would she know Lionel? Zip, she's gone again.
Clark and Lana break into the Dinsmore home, and hear a voice in the basement. Clark uses a flashlight, making us wonder why he doen't just turn on the lights - well, again, for dramatic effect only. Emily's room is just as she left it years earlier, with toys, dolls, and a diary. In a sub-basement, they find an entire lab full of suspended-animation chambers, one housing yet another Emily, apparently being kept alive by artificial means. When Lana spills the always-present meteor rock, Clark is agitated and eager to leave. The truth about Dinsmore is slowly being revealed; the script is well-paced to keep up the suspense.
Dinsmore has apparently been successful in cloning his dead daughter, and attempting to give her the memories of the original Emily. Clark returns later to find Emily, or her clone. He explains to her that the real Emily died. Emily disappears; Lex appears. Clark explains the cloning lab; Lex explains that at Luthrocorp, Dinsmore was experimenting with use of meteor rock to "Accelerate" cell growth. Now we have the big picture, and only the force behind this conspiracy is to be revealed.
Next time Emily appears to Lana, she's less terrified, but Emily super-speeds away to the river; Lana follows. At the hospital, Lex, as expected, sees an opportunity to exploit the situation. He offers to protect Emily II; Dinsmore says that Emily has no conscience and is dangerous. At the bridge with Emily, Lana tellis her the story of the accident suffered by first Emily. The little clone shoves Lana into the raging current, but Clark dives in to the rescue, then does CPR on her abdomen, but she recovers anyway.
Lionel visits to see Lex, who accuses him of reopening Level 3 and genetically-engineering human beings. Lionel dismisses this as science fiction, but then drops the news that he has managed to wrest control of the caves from Lex.
Lana comes back to see Clark, expressing gratitude for his protection, but she finds it difficult to live up to his perfect image of her - someday, she fears, she may disappoint him. Smallville never has any pointless dialog - this fear must portend some future storyline. Clark reassures her that nothing could ever change the way he feels; now she may need to start believing in him. Lionel has decided to tell Dinsmore that the cloning project must end. Dinsmore is still attached to Emily II as his daughter, but Lionel callously calls her the property of Luthorcorp, and brings her a gift - a white rabbit. Knowing what she did to Dinsmore, why is Lionel so confident about being close to her? As the camera pulls back, we see Emily is in her room, but the room is within a lab, and she will continue to be a Luthorcorp experiment. Nice surprise wrapup to this surprising episode. Although Lionel seems to be more sinister than ever, we should withhold judgment for a few more episodes, or even seasons. The Lionel character has a remarkable ability to reveal motivations that aren't always as evil as we first think. One of the better episodes of the season, partly due to our growing realization of the conspiracy behind what began as a mere "ghost" story. The fine acting, script, and great music make this a good one for another view. Re-run rating B.moreless