Lex continues his "Descent" into the darkness of evil, believing that Lionel has committed the ultimate betrayal of him. Clark and Chloe continue to search for answers about Veritas, while Jimmy and Lois investigate a murder photo.moreless
8.5
"Great"
"Descent" continues the increasing tension of the previous two episodes, through which the Veritas organization is revealed as a means of protection for the coming of the Traveler to Earth. Composed of families which have been featured in several previous seasons of Smallville, this series of related stories is a masterful creation of an entire history of the mission of Kal-El, and of those who either attempted to insure his success, or attempted to exploit him for their own purposes. The many previous storylines and episodes leading to this conclusion must be known and understood to truly appreciate how complex the screenwriting became in order to make the current and upcoming episodes not only plausible, but gripping and exciting to watch.
Lionel's life of misdeeds and conspiracies are catching up with him, and are becoming known in full by Lex, the one most affected by Lionel's lust for power. Lionel is seeking redemption by protecting Clark from...Zoners? Brainiac? Bizarro? The specifics aren't brought out in either "Traveler" or "Veritas," as both Clark and Chloe have no desire to ever listen to another story from him. And Lex is remembering scenes and conversations overheard during his childhood, pre-meteor shower. The departure of a major cast member was known before this episode was aired, and the speculation added to the tension.
When the ultimate confrontation takes place, the events of some 15 years earlier have become known by Lex, and he sees them as a fatal betrayal of his early life and his destiny by a father who cared more about the power of the Traveler than the well-being of his own son. Lionel tries another subterfuge - telling Lex that he is the Traveler...all the mysterious healings and escapes from death are evidence. Lex pulls a gun, knowing that he will find his answers in the safety deposit box in a bank in Zurich - he realizes that Lionel has the second key, and yanks it from his neck chain. Lionel's last words, "Lex, if you open that box, if you get hold of that secret, there will be no redemption for you, no redemption, ever." He sees that Lex will make the same mistake he did - Lex will be seduced by the ability to control the Traveler, and gain ultimate temporal power. Lex watches his own father plunge to his death from the Luthorcorp tower.
This is merely the opening scene! The continuing search for traces of Kara and Brainiac seems almost trivial after that. But Chloe and Clark press on until interrupted by the news from next door at Luthorcorp. Lex identifies the body as Lionel, even as he feigns innocence - yet Mr. Rosenbaum carries this scene off superbly, exhibiting remorse and defiance all in the same scene, as he visualizes his own youthful self - Alexander - accusing him of murder, and sees a face in the crowd - Clark, who may finally realize his error in refusing to listen to Lionel and to take the locket containing the key.
Gina, an aide to Lex who clearly has feelings for him, expresses sympathy - as Lex continues his act. She understands how he got the locket - but it's empty. Lex suspects Lionel gave it to someone, and Gina reports that Lionel stopped at the DP earlier. His younger self appears again, working on his guilt, and sending him into a rage. His conscience and potential redemption diminish with each scene.
Clark invades the crime scene at Lionel's office, and finds in the vault a cylinder lighted with kryptonian symbols. In an effective and mysterious scene, he activates the cylinder, which projects a visual message from Lionel. It's a warning - two keys exist, and they unlock the means of controlling Kal-El, and Clark must now save himself.
Jimmy has found in some of his photos from Lex's office an image of Lionel falling from his office, and another person in the darkness. Lois suggests using Lana's ISIS equipment to enhance and enlarge the photo. Chloe finds in her desk the other key - left by Lionel - even as Lex enters, pretending to be looking for family heirlooms. Chloe is at her lowest in protecting Clark, clumsily hiding the key in plain view in her desk drawer; Lex finds it, and summarily fires Chloe. This is another Smallville milestone - Chloe is suddenly launched on another career, not involving journalism.
In another maddening and dangerous move, Jimmy sends Chloe a plain text message about the photo of Lionel's fall, and it's easily spotted by Gina after Lex leaves the DP office. Our cast of heroes is falling way behind Lex - he is running circles around them. And Lois and Jimmy are soon looking down the barrel of Gina's gun. Jimmy's again depicted mostly as an ineffectual boob, while Lois tries heroics and gets shot for her bravery. After stashing the two in a freezer room, Gina is off to hit the 'delete' key for the photo on the ISIS server. Jimmy's only attempt to escape involves shouting through the door glass - most people would try to break it out and open the door.
Chloe's part in this episode is similarly frustrating - she has withheld significant information from Clark on Lionel's visit, and even now does not clarify it, until Clark mentions the keys. Finally! By now, there's a couple cast members and writers I could just slap.
So Clark invades the mansion, finding the locket with little effort, but no key. Lex catches him red-handed, and the two have words about Lionel's death - the usual denials and accusations. Meteor freaks, alien ships, cryptic symbols, Lex shouts...and he has a point. His paranoia is justified - the Earth is being threatened by alien forces, and he's acting as protector. It makes a lot of sense from his viewpoint. But like Lionel, Clark only talks about delusions - that line is just not going to cut it any more. Mr. Rosenbaum does another superior acting job in this verbal confrontation.
As Chloe continues enhancing the murder photo, Gina slips in and brains the clueless Chloe, who hasn't so much as locked the door. Gina erases the photo files as Clark arrives, shouting Chloe's name before he enters so any intruder can hide, and Gina does. Please, writers, is it necessary to dumb down the cast in every scene? Is anyone going to do anything right and/or heroic here? As he finds her on the floor, Clark doesn't even do a sweep of the complex. This is just rookie police work, folks. Then Clark and Chloe blab out his secret, and the danger of the keys, so Gina can overhear everything. Oh well, this just means that she's a dead woman.
Clark rescues Jimmy and Lois at the DP, thawing them with heat vision without being seen. Heroics as last. As Gina leaves a message for Lex stating that she knows the identity of the Traveler, she's put away for good, presumably by one of Lex's thugs. Hope he got the message, but regardless, he's planning a little trip to Zurich. His young self, played by Connor Stanhope, probably for the last time, appears again, having a dialog with Lex, but he retorts, "I'm done listening to you," as he puts aside the last vestige of his conscience.
Clark continues to beat himself up about the death of Lionel, his father, and Jor-El, as Chloe tries to talk some sense into him, offering the definition of evil as "the total absence of love." Interesting thought. At least Clark resolves to stop Lex from opening the safety deposit box.
Lex and Clark see one another again, at the cemetery, where Lionel is laid to rest in a rather ordinary grave. No words pass between them, but we all say goodbye to a long and compelling characterization by John Glover. He brought great skill to the part, often making us wonder if he was truly as evil as he appeared, but balancing that with insights into a person who eventually became one of Clark's greatest protectors, and who attempted to shield the world from the threat posed by his own son. Thank you, Mr. Glover.
"Descent" is a series classic, primarily for the significant developments, if not for the characterizations of the major cast members, who are depicted as inept and slow to react to threats. But so what? It's part of a trilogy, and even more episodes must reveal the growing threat of Lex and his knowledge of the Traveler. The season-ending episodes may continue along these lines, and if the dramatic tension can be sustained by good scripts and acting, especially by Mr. Rosenbaum, we might have an eight-episode must-see series. By itself, this episode gets only a C+ for a re-run rating - it should have been a B+, but at least it's elevated to that level as part of the Veritas story.moreless