Pete happens on a vehicle accident, and turns up Clark's spacecraft, putting his secret in jeopardy. Dr. Hamilton nears the truth about the craft, and threatens Pete's life.
8.0
"Great"
Joe Morton makes another guest shot as Dr. Hamilton - a great actor who is always an asset to any film in which he appears. Hamilton's increasingly agitated state has alarmed his assistants, and Lex has decided to end his financial support of Hamilton's meteor rock research. Hamilton drives off on a foggy night in a Jeep Liberty, a sure sign that there's going to be a collision. This time, however, the other driver veers into a corn field, and Hamilton flees. Pete is next on the scene in his '64 or so Ford Falcon convertible. I'd make a cell call first for help, but Pete runs out there to find the driver hanging by his seat belt, and a strange object nearby. It's Clark's ship, lost in the tornado in "Vortex" two weeks ago.
Next day Pete excitedly comes to the farm to get Clark and the pickup. The spaceship is there, but so is the van. The script has a slight hole here in failing to explain that Pete must have taken the driver for medical attention himself, and did not make a 911 call. Pete is enthusiastically convinced it's alien; Clark always tries to downplay these obvious exposes, but usually gets nowhere.. They haul it to Pete's toolshed, where Clark tries to quash Pete's starry-eyed dreams of fame and the talk show circuit.
Jonathan and Martha suggest stealing the spaceship back; Clark favors telling Pete the truth, but reluctantly agrees that his secret would impose a great responsibility on anyone.
Side plots have Lionel, still blind, coming to stay for a few days at the mansion, and another having Lana's Aunt Nell in a new relationship, but these are pretty much minor issues that don't need much attention.
At the hospital, Dr. Hamilton sees the accident victim, who had first claimed to have seen a spacecraft in the cornfield, and now remembers that Pete pulled him out of his van. The driver recognizes Hamilton, who has to up the man's i.v. dosage of something to puts him out cold. Or maybe it's murder - that's not clear.
Next night, Pete sees Clark and Jonathan retrieve the spacecraft, clearly a bonehead move, because Pete spots them. We have to have a story, but the plot would make more sense if Clark sped in and grabbed the craft. Next day, Pete waits for Clark at the farm, who begins by denying the theft. Pete drives off in a huff, intending to tell Chloe, but in a decisive and eye-catching move, Clark physically blocks Pete's car - "Pete, we have to talk." Here is a major development in the Smallville story - another person learning Clark's true identity, and Pete doesn't take it well, looking at Clark in an entirely new way. He leaves, only to be met by Clark at school next day, but Pete is still understandably angry at the many lies he now realizes Clark told him over years of friendship. Good story line so far.
Dr. Hamilton comes to Lex again, more agitated, demanding the octagonal key, knowing where it fits. But Lex simply says it disappeared during the storm. Hamilton stalks out, but corrals Lionel and offers a deal.
Even Chloe is on to the story, hearing about the van driver's rambling about a spaceship in the corn field, and she knows Pete was there. This is a classic situation of damage control, and Clark is not always skilled at this kind of maneuvering, relying mostly on lame excuses and transparent half-truths.
Lex awaits Clark at the farm - Clark is 'way too calm in the light of recent developments. Lex is having a similar experience with Lionel - apparently conciliatory, but with too many deceptions in the past, and Lex cannot take him at face value. Clark hears the applicability of this precaution to his own dilemma with Pete. But Lex provides a valuable clue to Clark - asking about the octagonal key - so Clark knows someone is getting close to opening the spaceship.
That would be Hamilton, who has taken Lionel to his lab, but Lionel is skeptical, being unable to see the object he's touching. Hamilton claims the ship's alloys are made of elements not appearing in the Periodic Table. Hard to buy that, since we assume that basic elements are common throughout the universe - any new ones are high on the Table, and highly unstable. "Get me the proof," Lionel replies. And Hamilton describes the disk, and the refusal of Lex to provide it. Clark counsels with Lana about resentment caused by telling the truth - but I think it most unwise of him to tell her about the conflict with Pete. Good friend that she is - she might question Pete, who might expose too much. Chloe knowing too much is enough already.
That night, Pete discovers Hamilton ransacking the tool shed - again, Pete foolishly takes matters into his own hands, instead of using that cell phone. Being thrown around by Hamilton just makes Pete blab about the ship and someone tougher than Hamilton, who now knows even more. Here's some instant karma - all the dangers associated with someone knowing too much about Clark affect Pete right here in the same episode. Back at the farm, Clark finally has to tell Jonathan and Martha that he told Pete everything. Life is about to change - they hear from Pete's mother that he's missing. These scenes and dialog make a lot of sense and play out just as one might expect - and that's good in this case.
Meanwhile, Nell tells Lana that Dean has proposed, and she said yes. More changes for Lana.
Hamilton has Pete roped up at his lab, but Pete still isn't talking. In a surprise move, Lionel asks Lex about the disk, and whether he has taken a look at Hamilton's barn lately. It's out of character for Lionel to yield any advantage on potentially-lucrative research or secrets, especially to Lex. The craziest phrase in the episode comes from Lex, who asks Lionel if he's after some "oedipal mano-a-mano." What a hoot. This is more than just gratitude for a few days stay at the mansion, but why would Lionel trust him?
Chloe to the rescue again - she has hospital visitor logs showing Hamilton visited the van driver before he expired. Zap, Clark's gone - about time. Hamilton is about to inject poor Pete with something bad, like meteor rock solution, when Clark blasts in. As usual, he saves someone, but green stuff is always around to slow him down. Pete frees himself, pulls Clark to safety, and Hamilton is left with green liquid dripping onto him, sending him into a frenzied seizure and death. End of Joe Morton's interesting tour on Smallville.
The spaceship is back home - maybe it needs a better hiding place. Pete is apologetic to Clark, who in turn is understanding of Pete. Lex and Lionel finally get to Hamilton's lab - too late - the ship is gone. The final plot hole is left unfilled - what happened to Hamilton's body? Did Pete report it? If so, how would he explain all the evidence of his presence? And if the authorities removed the body, why didn't Lex and Lionel hear about it before showing up there? And why wasn't there a crime scene restriction - with all the evidence of violence, you'd expect that. But you won't get it in a typical Smallville episode, because the bodies just disappear.
Other than the final corpse questions, "Duplicity" is a pretty fine episode, probably the best so far for Sam Jones, as he plays the (finally) loyal friend, and new member of the Kent family. With Clark's secret out to at least one more person, this is a good episode to see again. Re-run rating B.moreless