12 years after a meteor shower hit, Clark Kent, who mysteriously appeared during the shower, saves the life of millionaire's son Lex Luthor. Meanwhile, a youth mutated in the storm is determined to get revenge on those who humiliated him. Decent Pilot...moreless
9.0
"Superb"
'Smallville' (billed by Channel 4 as 'Smallville: Superman the Early Years') debuted here in the United Kingdom on New Year's Eve 2001 (in a feature-length version with the second episode, 'Metamorphosis'). I love a wide range of adventure / fantasy TV, and don't mind the 'Superman' movies, but have never really been a comic book fan (as in, I don't really read comic books; I don't mind big and small screen adaptations of them). But that's fine you don't need to be an uber-fan for this show; in fact you don't need to know much about 'Superman' history at all.
The setting takes some light liberties here and there with the original canon although this naturally irked some uber-fans, personally I don't have a problem with this; I think if they had stuck with previous version(s) word-by-word, it would have severely limited the scope of the series. And either way, it is much better than the horrible 'Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman' of the 1990s!
I loyally followed 'Smallville' for the first season or so, it being one of the few such shows that thankfully was not snatched by $ky; But from the second season, it started darting around the schedules a bit Channel 4 seeming unsure what to do with it, after it's previous 6pm slot during the week become unavailable due to (dire) teen soap 'Hollyoaks' going five night per week. It started popping up on Freeview channel E4 (which I didn't have back then), later to be repeated on Channel 4, but due to the often changing schedule and various other factors in my life at that time, I kind of lost track of the show. It is only now, in 2011 and with it announced that the show's tenth season will be it's last, that I've decided to watch the series in it's entirety on DVD.
When it was first shown, in the U.K. at least, there were immediate comparisons with 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer'. Yes, there are definite similarities (especially with 'Buffy's earlier episodes, which featured a wider-array of creatures to duel), and 'Buffy's popularity definitely opened the gateway for various other teen-angst-and-monsters shows. But personally, I really like both shows, and don't see why people feel need to continually compare them, insisting one liking on and not the other. They both have their individual merits.
The cast is generally very good: Tom Welling is likeable as Clark, and Michael Rosenbaum shows potential for a lot of coming storylines over Lex. A mixed ethnicity Lana is an interesting take, but Kristen Kreuk does well enough in the role; though I'm not yet sure about Chloe and Pete I found them hard to warm to, especially Chloe; maybe they'll grow on me. Annette O'Toole has nice a previous tie to the Superman franchise after playing the role of adult Lana in 'Superman III' (1983), but the real pull for me was John "Bo Duke of Hazzard" Schneider. I grew up loving those many classic action-adventure shows of the 1980s, and 'The Dukes of Hazzard' comes close second only to 'The A-Team' as my all-time favourite TV show (hey, I openly admit it!), so if nothing else, I tuned in to this Pilot to see how well he did.
For the most part, this Pilot sets up the scene very well, putting in place several on-going strands Lex's debt over Clark saving his life, yet his curiosity about the super powers Clark seeming to show in the rescue; Jonathan's distrust and dislike of the Luthors, and Clark's unrequited love for Lana Lang. Oh, and various people who have suffered various mutations as a result of the meteor shower 12 years previously!
Although probably not a classic of the series, the Pilot contains some nice moments, although also some bad ones too in particular, the cemetery scene, with Clark telling Lana the thoughts of her dead parents, is pretty cringeworthy!! I also found how Clark came to be wearing Lana's Kryptonite necklace to be very forced and over-convenient, and the resolution to the story's "guest mutant character" is resolved too quickly and far too simply. In fact, the "guest mutant" of this story felt in some ways to be tacked on as an afterthought. Another thing I felt, was that I would have liked it to have been made clearer that Clarke is not fully aware of his alien origins until Jonathan tells him at the conclusion of this episode.
Filming and production is generally good obligatory ballad-indie rock music et al. Also of note are the effects; in general, I'm not much of a CGI fan, preferring "old school" stunt work and effects, but for the likes of this series, I feel the CGI effects work well, and, from what I've seen so far, are only used where deemed appropriate, not in a gratuitously.
This Pilot looks set for a number of interesting plots to unfold, and I look forward to the following stories. I give this first episode a respectful 9/10.moreless