This backstory episode shows Lex in conflict with his classmates, including Oliver Queen, in a private academy. Together, they caused the death of another classmate, and someone is getting revenge for their deed.moreless
8.0
"Great"
This week, the writers are filling in the background of Lex, although there seems to be little reason for doing this now, as it has no particular relation to previous episodes. Lex had attended Excelsior Academy back in 1996, which would place his age at about 26 years at the series present, and Clark just graduated from Smallville High last season, so presumably he's 19 now. Actual ages at the time - Rosenbaum 34, Welling 29! So don't look to see if Lex looks just ten years older than Lucas Garbeel, who played the young Lex.
Lex and his good friend are mistreated by older students, including Oliver Queen, all rich snobs. Then-Lex can't be a senior, so he's only about 16, perhaps a sophomore, but already bitter about his treatment. In present day flash-forward, he attends a reunion at the Academy with Lana, but he has business objectives in mind. Lois and Oliver are there, too, but classmate Duncan isn't there, everyone notes, so we have a setup and a skeleton in Lex's closet. As one of their former classmates stands in the wrong place, a sword falls from a statue high above on a building, impaling him. End of pleasant reunion, and the opening scene.
Lionel visits Lex about the untimely death. Lionel knows Lex had an unpleasant time at Excelsior, he recommends burying those memories. Flash back again; young Lex is bitter about his father too, as he tells friend Duncan. They see other Oliver and friends stealing answers to mid-terms.
In the concurrent plot, Chloe is hanging at the Kent farm, concerned about strange happenings all over the world, maybe related to other escapees from the Phantom Zone, or Zoners for short. Clark wants to know for sure. Chloe knows that Oliver's company had satellite coverage, so photos of craters may identify the Zoners' landing spots.
As one of the former Academy classmates leaves the hospital in a Lincoln Town Car with a telltale fuel leak, boom, another of the group is dead. This is looking like a pattern. And Oliver gets a visit from Clark back in his apartment, seeking the info Chloe needs. Oliver agrees to give Chloe the access codes; in return he wants Clark to find out how Lex caused the death of his friends.
Back to the past, Lex and Duncan have to decide what to do with the test-answer information, but Duncan won't play along, he wants to turn them in. But Lex has already sold out Duncan, just to be one of the in-crowd. Young Lex beats the stuffing out of Duncan, while in the present, Lex has a bad dream, but then he has plenty of material to supply lots of nightmares. Lana offers to talk, as strange power fluctuations start, and Lana's injured as they duck a falling light fixture, putting Lana in the hospital. Lex can out-argue Clark any time, and keeps Clark from visiting Lana. Lois is investigating the deaths of Lex's friends, and Clark can't stop her from pushing ahead with her story.
Clark and Oliver discuss the accidents, and the crew does a nice photography job and interesting adult dialog between the two. We are so grateful this cast is allowed to speak standard English! Oliver says he and Lex killed Duncan 10 years ago - and we see how in the scene after Lex beat Duncan bloody. Duncan had staggered into the path of a car and was fatally injured. Lionel funded neurosurgery for Duncan, but he died two days later. Oliver says all four of them contributed to Duncan's death. Is Duncan's family taking late revenge? Unlikely.
At Luthorcorp, Lionel studies kryptonian symbols, as Clark comes in and drops the Duncan name. They try to identify the assailant; Lex may be next in the body count. Lionel was involved, telling Clark that Duncan is still alive, in a vegetative state - he funded research on reversing the damage to Duncan's brain, in exchange for Duncan's mother keeping silent. Let's find Duncan.
in a lab where everything is shaded blue (why is that considered stylish?), except green fluids, Duncan continues to get treatment. Lois and Clark have come to the facility, Clark apparently having Lionel's blessing to barge in and investigate.
Lex is in to see Oliver, suspecting Oliver in many recent tragedies. Oliver thoughtlessly reminds Lex of his assault on Duncan and gets a right cross for it. Oliver gets in the second blow, but suddenly the windows begin to rattle, and one blows in as Oliver gets Lex out of the way. That sort of leaves Lex out of the culpability list. Clark and Lois have found Duncan, whose being treated with meteor-rock-based fluids; Duncan's charts show the injections match the times of assaults on the classmates. Duncan's brain is in overtime, his consciousness projected far beyond the limitations of his body, and in a form of astral projection, controls an arrow in Oliver's loft and fires it into Oliver. He's saved from another, fatal arrow only by Clark's intevention, and the psychic force of Clark's resistance causes Duncan to expire. Duncan's pain is ended, and Lois is going to drop the story. They could have shown a bit more sympathy for Duncan's suffering. Someone, Clark perhaps, could have shown sorrow.
Back at the mansion, Lex tells Lana about his unfortunate experience, even about betraying Duncan. She still has faith in him. Oliver drops in, invited by Lex, who takes the trouble to thank Oliver for the save, and Oliver offers some regrets for the way he treated Lex and Duncan years ago, but they still part adversaries.
Lex confronts Lionel about the experimentation on Duncan; they both look bad in this scene. Lex wants more information on Duncan's treatment - he must be seeing an income opportunity.
At the farm, Oliver and Clark discuss astral projection and other everyday subjects. Chloe arrives and finally meets Oliver, saying cousin Lois talks about him all the time. The crater images she discovered helped, but there's many more of them, so more Zoners have come to Planet Earth. That should be good for one episode apiece. Clark looks at one photo from Australia; it shows a person in the crater - Raya, the Kryptonian who helped Clark escape from the PZ back in "Zod," the season opener. Another follow-on story coming.
Reunion sounded like a boring story - why are the school days of Lex of any interest? But it turned out to be much better, giving the basis for the antagonistic Lex-Oliver relationship, Oliver building closer ties with Clark, and Oliver meeting Chloe. As for Lionel, his actions can always be interpreted as either potentially helpful, or as more evidence of true evil. Actions speak louder that speculation - Lionel is one of the good guys, he's just an inept father who's trying to atone for some serious damage done to Lex. Re-run rating B.moreless