South Park

Season 17 Episode 8

A Song of Ass and Fire

10
Aired Wednesday 10:00 PM Nov 20, 2013 on Comedy Central
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (4)

8.5
out of 10
Average
58 votes
  • Best episode of the series so far

    8.0
    Yes, this is the best episode of the series so far. But, I can't help but feel that Trey and Matt could have done a much better job of lampooning GOT 5 or 10 years ago. I like the recurring "betrayal garden" gag, but there are scenes that immediately spring to mind when you try to imagine what would happen if South park did a GOT episode, and many are missing. For example, when Cartman was overseeing the boys practicing with wooden swords, I thought, "It would be so awesome right now if Cartman used some of Syrio Forels lines" . And that has happened quite a few times in this trilogy so far. Even the gag about the authors obsession with gay wiener isn't especially funny because it's just not true. I've counted! The gay wiener count is exactly 0. I didn't count straight wiener, but - off the top of my head, it's like 3 or 4.

    This episode would get a 10 if I were only comparing it to the rest of this season. Overall it gets an 8. But if it were in season 8 or 10 for example, I'd rate it a 6.
  • weak episode... but it's piggy in the middle

    7.0
    As the reviews stated below, the wiener joke just falls flat on its face. There's so much material to make fun of, why make stuff up? As far as I can recall, there was no gay wiener, and very few flaccid straight wiener. And really, compared to the 60 or so boobs and vagina shots... are we really that gayphobic?



    Beyond that joke though (which they really kept emphasizing) it was an... OK episode. The garden scene was funny, and so was Kenny as the princess. The president of Sony was humorous as well.



    The problem is this looks like one of south parks classic 3 episode arc story lines. But if you don't watch all these together, the middle one really fizzes out, having neither a beginning nor an end.



    I'll give this a episode a generous 7 out of ten. Not the worst out of this season but definitely not the best.
  • Gay Weiners

    8.0
    I agree with the review below mine. The show could have done much more biting satire. It seems they have toned down the scathing, insults, celebrity lampoons and truily controversial subjects. When you think as far back (and this is a LONG time ago now to the infamous Chicken

    n show is just so TAME now. . It was an enjoyable yet not hilarious episode. I also agree they did not hit hard enough making fun of GOT and the shows *there are many now' just like it.



    I don;t know WHY they put TIMMY in the show anymore. He actually has not said "TIMMY" in over 2 years. They stopped doing Timmy and Jimmy episodes

    of those were the funniest in the entire series (Cripple Fight example. Cartman did nothing truly offensive or even an OMG Cartman moment all season. Too many complaints? too many hassles, lawsuits, ,

    meetings with COmedy Central knows. But the BITE is missing.
  • part 2

    8.5
    what i liked- George . Martin, the newscasters' being revealed as incestual, the ending, another Garden of Betrayal Scene.



Today
10:20am
COMEDY
5:55pm
COMEDY
11:00pm
COMEDY
11:30pm
COMEDY
Saturday
6:25pm
COMEDY
7:00pm
COMEDY
7:30pm
COMEDY
8:00pm
COMEDY
8:30pm
COMEDY
Sunday
2:05am
COMEDY
2:30am
COMEDY
3:00am
COMEDY
3:30am
COMEDY
4:05am
COMEDY
More
Less