The perfect way to end the saga of a man killed by Scientology.
8.5
"Great"
Ah yes, Isaac Hayes. August 20, 1942 - August 10, 2008.
Known as a legendary R&B singer (and admittedly a very good one, back in the day), he made another claim to fame outside his musical career: the voice of Jerome "Chef" McElroy, the overweight cafeteria worker at South Park elementary who, if asked a question relating to sex in some way, will break into inappropriate songs at a moments notice.
And a Scientologist.
Now, don't get me wrong. I respect Scientologists - they have just as much right to believe in Xenu as I (a Buddhist) have to believe in Buddha. However, there are some aspects of the religion which are downright creepy. Case in point, recruitment.
Scientology will prey on customers, suckering them in by convincing them they're depressed. Scientology does have the right to follow as they wish; it's just the depression element that doesn't sit right.
Anyway, they then get their customers to take a series of courses which gradually brainwashes them, convincing them that each time a higher course is taken, they will become less depressed. Eventually, gradually, the courses taken drill into their minds, and they now feel that Scientology is everything; should you diss the religion, you are now the enemy. To me, that's creepy. And unfortunate.
Back to topic - this episode aired 9 days after Isaac Hayes' sudden departure from the series on the basis that Parker & Stone had mocked his personal religion, Scientology. Parker and Stone agreed to the deal, but it wouldn't be without its consequences.
The episode begins with a "previously on South Park" (not a flashback to an actual episode). In this, the boys are distraught to learn that Chef is leaving them for the recently discovered "Super Adventure Club." In this episode, it's announced he's returning to South Park - but at the celebration at Jimbo and Ned's, Chef talks for the first time, and something seems wrong with his voice. It seems wrong, disjointed - not so subtly made up from spliced voice footage from past episodes. The next day, the boys are horrified when Chef starts talking about wanting to have sex with them. Upon investigation, they learn that he's been brainwashed by the Super Adventure Club - a not so subtle parody of Scientology, whose organization is devoted to molesting children. This is based on reports that L. Ron Hubbard, the founder of Scientology, was a child molester himself, and also accused Jesus of such acts.
Anyway, the boys rescue Chef, and tell him to come back with them, and that they love him - but he can't bring himself to do it, instead beginning to return to the club. On the way, however, he is struck by a lightning bolt, and falls to his very gruesome death. Following a memorial service back in South Park (attended by Elton John, Kathie Lee Gifford and Terrance & Phillip, among others), Chef is reconstructed as "Darth Chef" by the Super Adventure Club, now completely converted.
This episode is brilliant, for a number of reasons. As the audience, you can feel the anger toward Hayes; Parker and Stone obviously aren't happy with his decision, which was a rather hypocritical move, but aren't outright referring to him as such. At the same time, they seem to understand his decisions, famously summed up by Stone:
"(We) never heard a peep out of Isaac in any way until we did Scientology. He wants a different standard for religions other than his own, and to me, that is where intolerance and bigotry begin."
Now, I'll say this. I do respect Scientology, and it is unfortunate that Hayes would die two years after the episode aired. At the same time, though, I can't deny that it was incredibly stupid on his part; after seeing every race, religion and nationality possible mocked for nearly ten years, Hayes quit when it personally offended him. By signing the contract, Hayes agreed to be potentially offended, and so for him to quit not only made him an imbecile, but also cast further doubt on Scientology.
Ultimately, I'm left with very strong feelings about the episode. I'm certainly not amused by the subject matter, but it perfectly dealt with the hypocrisy of Hayes' decision, and was damn well pulled off.moreless