Space: Above and Beyond

Season 1 Episode 5

Mutiny

0
Aired Sunday 7:00 PM Oct 15, 1995 on FOX
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (5)

8.0
out of 10
Average
63 votes
  • should have been titled Tank Rights

    7.0
    This episode deals with some aspects of humanity. They deal who has "human" rights. They display the problem of what's debated now. Do clones or Tanks as they are referred to, have the same right as natural born people? What is neat about this episode is that is written as if there is three classes of people, natural born, tanks and marines. While there is sufficient action, this one focuses more on Hawkes and how he deals will bring a tank and a marine. He is given a decision being a marine and choosing a dream of finding family. The alien encounter was drawn out throughout the episode and given the capabilities of the aliens it should have been a thirty second battle. I still cant get over watching them use 1990 weapons and pistols.
  • Disproportionally unappreciated.

    9.6
    I can't remember the exact details, but this episode definately left an impression on me. It posed difficult moral questions that are relevant above and beyond just war, but in social behaviour at large. The ship becomes a microcosm of today's society, of wealthy exploiters and a poorer subdued underclass in poor working conditions. One could also see a spill-over into the abortion debate. None theless, the scores show this to be the least apprecated episode... it can't possibly be worse than 'Level of Necessity', the necessity of which could be questioned but for a weak attempt at developing Damphousse's character. It only succeeds in underlining how auxillary she is in every other episode.
  • Another great episode.

    10
    This time the 58th are guarding a transport carrying a cargo of invitros. The 58th are flying their hammerheads this week, but it's alright, the action still takes place in space. The effects are cool, in this episode we get to explore the character of Cooper Hawkes. He finds out that he has an invitro sister onboard the cargo ship he and his squadron were assigned to guard. We get to see his soft spot in this episode, we learn even though he has a reckless behavior, he is also so human inside. This episode was a bit sad, but it's still a very good one.
  • Another sad day for Hawkes

    8.2
    We return back to SAaB's good form with this episode. The story is simple but becomes complicated quickly. The 58th are assigned to guard a cargo on a freighter, but this is no ordinary cargo. The cargo is a consignment of thousands of workers in cryogenic stasis, with several hundred of them being invetro's.
    Hawkes feels immediately involved and suffers from a personal loneliness that is the result of his harsh and isolated upbringing. He must know if any of the invetro's came from the same place he did, if any of them could be his 'family'. He discovers that he has a sister, although not a biological one, amongst the invetros.
    When the freighter comes under attack by the Chig equivalent of a U-boat, an emergency shortage of power causes the captain to order the invetro chambers disconnected. The invetros amongst the crew refuse the order, and stage a mutiny. Hawkes and to a lesser extent McQueen are torn between saving the ship and saving the invetros, a decision which become even harder when the captain is killed placing McQueen in charge. After some difficult moments, McQueen orders the invetros disconnected. Hawkes, knowing its the right thing to do, is the one to push the button that ends his sisters life.
    There is powerful acting all around in this episode, Rodney Rowland really shines as struggles with Hawkes's emotions, and James Morrison is strong as always.
    With its good direction, interesting story and an unhappy but 'feel good' ending, this is an episode you don't want to miss.
  • Informative Show

    8.4
    Mutiny, interesting show for the most part!

    This one deals with the 5-8 having to board a freighter to get them to the USS Saratoga. However, they get caught up in an internal struggle amongst the crew and and external conflict with an enemy ship that is hounding them.

    This episode tells us more about the Invitro's and their history. it also reveals to us how Invitro's define 'family'. Mostly they look for commonalities with their gene pool, DNA strands, and conception facility.

    It's kind of a filler episode, but the internal conflicts amongst the crew and the external attacks from the Chig Battleship feels like a condensed version of Crimson Tide. Good show all around.

    -Nuff Said
Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
More
Less