SpongeBob SquarePants

Season 4 Episode 11

Whale of a Birthday / Karate Island

Aired Weekdays 5:00 PM May 12, 2006 on Nickelodeon

Episode Fan Reviews (46)

out of 10
183 votes
  • To be dead honest, Whale of a Birthday was okay, but Karate Island.....

    Now, Whale of a Birthday was okay. I don't see why everyone hates it so much. It had a few funny parts, but still; the singing troupe wasn't necessarily at all. I found the Squidward singing part hilarious, and another couple of chuckles, but that's about it.

    Overall Score: C (6.5).

    But now we see this dreadful piece of shite from a buffalo. What the hell? At first, the episode might be average, but the episode literally gets worse by the second. And the ending; a condo? Where did that come from? The Sandy battles were a pain to watch too.

    Overall Score: D (2.5)

    Overall, Whale of a Birthday should have been paired with another episode.

    Overall Mean Score: 4.0