I have watched all ST series and was excited when I realized a new one was coming.
After watching it my verdict are so-so.
What I liked:
- Back to the basics.
- More military style and less lounge like.
- The beginning of space travel with only 4.5 warp.
- Beginning of weaponry and beam me up tech.
- The characters - they all act their ass of and I loved everyone one of them.
What I dislike:
Main story arc are taking to long - a whole season only focusing on the story. This is not true Star Trek. Star Trek is each episode are new, exciting, what will happen, who will they encounter, how will they get out of it.
SPOILER: And to be honest - the story that the Xindi will destroy Earth for an unknown reason (if there is one, it eluded me). Come on writers - you can do better than that. Seriously.
Bottomline is a 6.5 from me based on:
- not true to the Star Trek as we know it.
- story arc that are lousy and not that exciting.