Star Trek: Enterprise

Season 1 Episode 12

Silent Enemy

4
Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM Jan 16, 2002 on UPN
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (6)

8.5
out of 10
Average
194 votes
  • Deadweight.

    5.0
    This episode is nothing but filler. I don't mean that nothing big happens, that is okay and sometimes good, like in Breaking the Ice, but here there is no character conflict and no character development. You don't leave the episode knowing the characters any better than when you arrive (except for the fact of doubtful importance that Malcolm likes pineapples).



    Malcolm has so far been an anti-character. We know nothing about him but his name and function. So it was at first a welcome fact that we would get an episode about him. The problem is that throughout the episode we don't learn anything new about the character except for the fact that apparently no one knows him well either. I guess this happens in the real world, people go by life without leaving a mark on anyone, but this makes for a hell of a boring character.



    I was also at first happy that we get to spend some time with Hoshi, she is very charming and played by a very good actress. But we get the same problem: there is no character growth and we don't get to learn anything about her. They could change Hoshi for any random Enterprise crew member, give the same lines and go out with the same effect. What a waste!



    About the A plot, the threat of the aliens seems real, and it manages to keep the episode from being downright bad. But since we don't get to know absolutely anything (really, we don't get even a single line from them) about these aliens, it is very hard to get any emotional weight on this issue. It is mildly entertaining, but can easily be skipped for something with real substance.
  • Unknown aliens attack Enterprise.

    3.1
    This episode can easily be skipped if you are a fan of Enterprise. One of the storylines focuses on what Malcolm's favorite food is. I won't spoil the reveal for those of you who are interested in such things. If you are interested, then this is the episode for you.

    The main storyline talks about a rather boring alien race that you know nothing about from beginning to end. They blow a few things up and that about covers it.

    This was a very boring and unnecessary episode. It seems like they had to have a certain number of episodes to fill a seasonal quota and this one made it by default.
  • excellent episode

    10
    Enterpise is attacked by an unidentified alien ship. The crew works to get their phaser canons to work. This episode really takes the show into combat mode. But it's not all about space battles, there's time for comedy as well. Hoshi is tasked by the captain to find out the perfect gift for their weapons officer. It's an excellent episode. The conflict with the unknown alien was the real feature of the episode, it's really exciting. the anticipation of the combat made this show really watchable. It's really nice, the writers surely did a good episode. I'm anxious to see more enterprise.
  • Enterprise is attacked by a mysterious enemy, that seems determined to conquer the ship and do something terrible to the crew. Meanwhile, it becomes clear that nobody really knows Malcolm very well, not even his parents...

    7.5
    I quite liked this episode.

    Ik liked the mysterious ship attacking Enterpise. The threat felt very real, and I liked the fact that no explanation was given at all to the reason these aliens behaved as they did. Pity, though, that they did show some of the aliens: I would have preferred it if they had remained totally faceless and mysterious.

    The fact that, when you go strolling through unknown places, far from home, you might encounter some friendly, but also some downright nasty characters is very well brought across here.

    Through improvisation and hard work the crew eventually managed to fend off the bad guys; that was well done too. If you run back home the first time you get into real trouble, you're not cut out to be an explorer.

    A downside to this episode was the B plot, about Malcolm being so inscrutinable that even his own parents didn't know his likes and dislikes; they didn't even know he had been in outer space onboard Enterprise for these last few months!
    Although I suppose these kind of side-plots are vital to the character development, I felt it was not very believable and it broke the tension built up so well in the main plot.
  • Strange invaders attack enterprise

    6.0
    this episode
    was quite an odd fish
    an alien vessel repeatedly attacks enterprise and retreats

    archer orders a return to jupiter station
    to complete the installation of the ships
    weapons systems
    Reed and tucker resolve to complete
    the refit before the aliens return.
    3 phase modulated partical cannons.

    The aliens eventually return and order archer to surrender his ship.

    he orders his new weapons to fire to little effect
    the aliens shields are still up
    and still closing on enterpise.

    Archer orders an overload to increase the yield
    of the cannons this rips the attackers shields apart
    and they quickly retreat.
    the senior staff celebrate by drinking beer in the amoury


    okay
    i grew up watching the 90s star trek
    i kinda assumed that it would turn out
    to be a missunderstanding like in darmok
    i guess
    the world has changed since then
    i was certain right up until the cake at the end that they would explain the aliens motivation.
    I kinda felt wrong footed
    i suppose the "caring 90s" where we had to understand our enemy (tng the wounded)left a deep impression on me.

    the aliens were just jerks and they got what was coming too them i suppose everytrek reflected the era it was made in
  • A bit of an insight into Lt. Reed....

    10
    The first real character development for Lt. Malcolm Reed comes in pretty much from the start of this episode. When Archer contacts Reed’s parents, it’s obvious from the outset that parents and child don’t have much in the way of communication. It seems Mrs Reed cares more about her son than her husband does, but it’s obvious that Malcolm didn’t say much (if anything) about his posting onboard Enterprise. It does seem he’s a little closer to his sister, although even she doesn’t know what his favourite food is. Maybe he didn’t have one when he was growing up? We learn he suffers from allergies, so maybe he wasn’t able to eat certain things back then that he can now? It’s also funny to see Hoshi’s attempts to engage Reed in conversation (so she can find out his favourite food) and the embarrassing moments when he thinks she’s making a (rather subtle) pass at him.

    What is interesting is that in this episode, Reed doesn’t appear to be as ‘pessimistic’ as he’s made out to be in other episodes (Minefield for example). The obvious distance between him and his father is brought up again in Minefield (when Archer mentions they didn’t know much about his assignment on Enterprise) and in the season 4 arc episodes Affliction and Divergence (when Archer asks how Malcolm’s father would feel about his son being court-marshalled).

    All in all, a very good character building episode for Malcolm. We learn a bit about his background and his time before he joined Enterprise, a little about his family and family history, and he gets to be a bit of a hero by getting the phase cannons built and installed with his armoury (and Trip’s engineering) crew.
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
More
Less