Star Trek: The Animated Series

Season 1 Episode 3

One of Our Planets is Missing

4
Aired Saturday 10:30 AM Sep 22, 1973 on NBC
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (3)

7.3
out of 10
Average
57 votes
  • One of our Planets is Missing follows a Trek tradition of Enterprise coming into path of super-being-like cloud floating in unknown space. Overall, the episode is thought-provoking by the end credits, but lacks somewhat in visuals and performance.

    5.0
    One of our Planets is Missing follows a Trek tradition of Enterprise coming into path of super-being-like cloud floating in unknown space. As the crew continues to research and investigate the clouds behaviour, it is established that the cloud feeds upon the energy and matter of full planets in order to survive. In order to save the lives of millions, the crew of the Enterprise must find a way to stop the being from destroying the planet.

    The story that of OPM is an interesting one, mainly because it doesn’t really go anywhere for the first 15 or so minutes and then finally gets to the real point, where finally something relevant is brought up for discussion rather than a bucket full of techno babble. For the most part however, and most importantly, this episode does strike at a very important issue in modern day lifestyles and of course, establishes and develops on a now well-known Trek philosophy.

    Performances are as a whole, average, with nothing neither really standing out nor crossing the line of dull.

    Visually, the episode is bland with a lot of re-used animations from previous episodes and by now I can tell already which ones I’ll probably see in nearly all the episodes to come. The alien-cloud being is decent enough but nothing spectacular, the direction of the Enterprise entering the being could have been done with greater realism however.

    Overall, One of our Planets is Missing is a thought-provoking episode by the end credits, but lacks somewhat in visuals and performance. Plus a well-developed introduction to the issue dealt with in the last third of the episode could have done it a world of good.

    5/10
  • The crew of the Enterprise must stop an energy cloud from consuming a populated planet.

    7.0
    It's a credit to the people involved with this series that they didn't feel the need to change Star Trek simply because they were doing it animated form. Others would have pandered to the younger viewers by having simplified stories with more visual gags and obnoxious sound effects; especially since this might have distracted viewers from limited movement in the animation. "One of Our Planets is Missing", like most of the episodes in this series, is Star Trek down to its core. Something dangerous is discovered, the crew of the Enterprise attempts to learn more about it, and reaching an understanding proves more effective than violence. That proves enough for a 24 minutes of entertainment.
  • The Enterprise has to stop an alien cloud from eating a planet populated by millions of people.

    6.0
    The worst part of this episode is that it is almost dull. There are many times I wasn't even paying attention due to the lack of a good story. It is your basic sci-fi romp, an alien is heading towards Earth, so Spock is needed to communicate with the being before it does something it will unknowingly do. The episode is alright, I suppose, but it is not that exciting. There are some parts that capture interest for a little while, but then it just seems to start dragging again. Overall, it's alright, but definitely not the best in the series.
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
More
Less