The Enterprise crew must find a way to exterminate malevolent parasites that have driven a colony insane, including the family of Kirk's brother. Things get even worse when Spock becomes the parasites' latest victim. A fair story but with awkward pacing..moreless
7.5
"Good"
This review contains spoilers.
"Operation - Annihilate!" is the final episode of 'Star Trek's classic, groundbreaking first season.
I don't know why, but for some reason, it feels somewhat like a 'left over' episode to me, especially being tagged on after a classic like "The City on the Edge of Forever", which would have made a perfect ending to the season. (The fact that on the DVD box set, it is on the final disk on its own (on the R2 version anyway, I don't know about elsewhere) makes it feel even more separated from the other episodes).
I find this quite a difficult episode to sum up. It has a fair story, but I find it awkwardly told, with some bad pacing and a few things that don't completely work.
The fact that Kirk's brother and his family have become victims of the parasites could have been good 'Trek' material, but extremely little is done with them to distinguish from standard 'victims of the week', and in the end, it just feels rather tacked on, and doesn't serve any real purpose.
The parasites themselves are interesting creatures, and while they may look a bit cheap by nowadays' standard (I wonder what they would have looked like in CGI), they still serve the purpose and look quite eerie in their own way.
Under the influence of the malevolent 'jelly' parasites, Leonard Nimoy gives a good performance of Spock, trying (even harder than normal) to keep himself in order.
The later development of Spock being blinded by the test also seems rather tacked on. If this had been introduced earlier in the episode, and been given time to build, it could have been very interesting, but stuck quite near the end of the story, it seems to come out of nowhere.
Likewise, as interesting as Spock's Vulcan body is of eradicating the blindness is, it all seems very convenient and a quick fix; almost like "Spock's blind! Oh, he's okay again".
But for all the bad things, this episode does serve up a reasonable story. There's certainly worse, in both the first season and Original 'Trek' as a whole.
This episode is also possibly my very earliest memory of watching 'Star Trek' as a young child. I remember watching it one evening on BBC 1 in the very early 1980s, on one of the series' many repeats by the Beeb. I can clearly remember the 'jelly bugs' swooping about and one landing on Spock's back. I must have been about four years old (which would date it around 1982).
All-in-all, this is quite a good episode, but let down by some awkward storytelling. If it had been better constructed and more polished, I think it would have possibly been one of the greats of the first season. As it is, it stands as a fair but, ultimately, a slightly disappointing outing.
---first season overview---
The first season of 'Star Trek' was ground-breaking, presenting a series of space-bound adventures that had not been seen on television before. Going beyond the 'monster of the week' tales of some other space set shows, 'Star Trek' offered up thoughtful and mostly well fleshed out stories.
Season one may in many ways be the best of the three seasons. The bulk of it is made up of top notch episodes, that are evenly balanced between adventure and drama. And as with all good 'Trek', there is a healthy dose of comedy mixed in, used sparingly and at the right moment.
It felt to find it's footing straight away. Second pilot "Where No Man Has Gone Before" stands as a very good episode, and first by first regular episode produced, "The Corbomite Maneuver", the template is set in place for the series.
Everyone has their favourites, but examples such as "Balance of Terror", "The Galileo Seven", "Errand of Mercy" and "The City on the Edge of Forever" stand out.moreless