No one can figure out Susan's costume for her Halloween party, and she's livid when Jack misses it and seems to be lying as to why; Luis doesn't care for Todd's new girlfriend—a witch
Todd goes to Susan's party dressed as Andre Agassi, the early years. Everyone tries, and fails, to name the actress that Andre married just before he changed his image, a joke playing on the fact that it was series star Brooke Shields.
Edit