A fascinating episode, for the first time creating a disturbing distinction between supernatural entities and evil ones.
9.5
I have always assumed, perhaps naively, that the things the Winchesters hunt are evil. It’s a natural assumption given they usually track supernatural beings by newspaper articles which report crimes. But that’s how the boys hunt, not necessarily John – John maybe used other sources, other hunters etc. We’ve also been told on many occasions that, especially in the early years, that John was dangerously obsessed, even irrational. We also know he had a drinking problem. But the boys cannot be held accountable for John’s hypothetical actions, so let’s focus on the boys: it’s not something that should worry the boys too much, their hunting methods are sound. But Dean’s knee-jerk reaction to kill the vampires when the only dead were cattle and the vampires themselves is worrying, Dean never questioned that, never wondered why there were no dead humans. As we’ve seen before, Dean is far more influenced by John than Sam ever was and with Dean’s emotional instability right now, it makes Dean extremely dangerous – but he’s as much a danger to himself as to others.
Notice how Ellen calmly tells Sam that Gordon’s a great hunter but her entire attitude changes when she realizes they’ve teamed up with him. When other hunters consider you a psychopath, maybe it’s time to take a long hard look at yourself. It’s a strange reversal of roles – used to be Dean who was the family protector, but for the first time, Sam’s got to watch out for Dean. And it is only going to get worse. Sammy’s really matured, he’s not the selfish brat he was when we first met him. I love seeing Sam worrying about Dean and he has reason to worry - Dean killing that vampire was just scary, and afterwards, so casual and joking about it. That was just terrifying. Shows how worried Sam is - they only met Ellen last week but now he immediately calls her to get a background on Gordon. I love Sammy so much, I'd adopt him if I could. How can two non-existent characters become so real you worry about them like they're family?
What scares me most about Gordon isn’t Gordon at all – it’s Dean. I don’t give a rat’s ass about Gordon, as long as he doesn’t hurt the boys. Gordon is what Dean would become without Sam, it’s that simple. Even Dean acknowledged that at the end. Dean is staring into the abyss, carrying a burden John should *never* have put on his shoulders, and the abyss is seeming more and more attractive. Dean can’t talk to Sam because he’s always been the ‘big brother’, the rock, unshakeable, he has to protect Sam – that’s the way Dean thinks. But it’s not just John – Sam’s also partly the reason for Dean’s deterioration, but Dean never blames Sam for that. Gordon was once exactly where Dean is now and is frighteningly charismatic, knowing just what to say to Dean to seduce Dean to the dark side. Gordon's 'black and white' speech was just about exactly what Dean wanted to hear - means he doesn't have to think about consequences or morality. When Gordon finished the conversation where he told Dean about his sister, the look in Dean’s eyes terrified me – his eyes were filled with almost reverence, I’ve never seen that look on Dean’s face before, not even with John.
Once fascinating thing did come out of talking with Gordon - a story about when Dean was 16. The writers tell us so little about their childhood that we grasp at every titbit they feed us. And for a while I actually warmed to Gordon - he praised John! That comment about how the boys fill John's shoes made me mushy! John wasn't a terribly pleasant person most of the time, the man had almost no friends! Even Bobby threatened to shoot him! But he was a good man and though not the best father, he loves those boys beyond reason. I still can't bear that he's gone. Dean's not the only one grieving.
Supernatural has always has at least ten minutes in every episode that focuses completely on the boys and/or John. This season has been exceptional and these moments are what drive the show. For me, the best scene was the confrontation between Dean and Sam, where Sam tells him that adopting Gordon as some sort of John-replacement is an insult to John’s memory. I understand totally why Dean hit him, the writers set it up flawlessly and Jensen was just magnificent, that fake strained smile was just the cherry on top. You could actually see him hitting Sam before it even happened. Jared was equally excellent. It was a fantastic scene.
I loved the whole vampire story, and not just because of the conflict it created. Lenore is eloquent – it *is* about survival, the only way they will survive is to not be a threat. They’ll never be safe though, there are too many hunters who think just like Gordon. She handled Sam perfectly – she knows they need an advocate for their cause and returning Sam unharmed was a huge act of faith, on both sides. The writers handled this beautifully.
Gordon’s mistake at the end was obvious – he attacked Sam. Until then, Dean was still wavering, despite Sam’s arguments, but nobody attacks Sam and gets away with it. Dean’s protectiveness of Sam is extreme and overrides anything else, even the obsessiveness driving Dean on this case. That is part of what changed Dean’s perspective – if Gordon was so out of control as to attack Sam, he could also be wrong about the vampires. But Lenore had the most to do with it - actually fighting the blood craving and refusing to drink. Impressive. The end was adorable, Dean literally squirming, telling Sam to hit him. Sam just doesn’t hold a grudge.
Speaking of Sam, I loved him correcting Gordon on the 'Sammy' thing - there was a time when he used to complain when Dean called him that too. I must admit it made me grin - it's Dean and Sam against the world.
On a lighter note, the beginning with the newly-restored Impala was very cute, it’s good to see her back. It broke my heart when she got hit by the truck, but it was actually worse seeing the damage at Bobby’s. She’s as much a character as the boys, the series wouldn’t be the same without her. Seeing Dean so happy is great, even if it doesn’t last. “Aww, don't listen to him, baby. He just doesn't understand us.” Hysterical!
This is a very layered episode, never failing to address building issues or existing ones and a great harbinger for coming episodes.