Another great episode, both surprising and expansive in terms of plot development. Dean and Sam encounter a boy who has the power to, unknowingly, warp reality to his own paradigms.
9.0
"Superb"
(Warning- spolier ahead)
Since there's so much to discuss from this episode I'm not really sure where to start. As others have mentioned, the show's abilty to amalgamate genres has really been quite the treat to watch unfold and expand as the seasons have progressed. It seems to posses a seemingly effortless strength to sift from light and comedic tones to dark and dramitic ones on the drop of a dime which is not something many shows are able to do. Also, I think props are owed to the casting directors on SPN. They seem to have this uncanny knack for finding great guest actors who, even if they don't get a lot of screen time, still steal the frame when they're on. This time was no exception.
However, what I really wanted to discuss was something I am surprised no one else has touched- Cas's definition of "the Anti-Christ" and its relation to Sam in earlier seasons. Half way through the show Castiel notes that the anti-christ is not Lucifer's child as is normally assumed, but simply a demon spawn- meaning any child derived from a the consumation of a demon and a human. This got me thinking about earlier episodes and seasons and remembering how in season 2 and 3 Sam is commonly reffered to by Gordon, demons, and others hunting him, as the anti-christ. It got me think about what if Gordon got it wrong? What if Sam wasn't "the anti-christ" but simply "an anti-christ"? Now, I have been wrong before on my predications and I certainly could be now, so exucse me if this sounds perposterous, but what if either John or Mary were possesed when they concieved Sam? As absurd as it might seem at first, it doesn't hurt to think about the facts supporting this argument. After all, we know Azazel, on Lucifer's orders (see the season 4 finale), was looking for a specific and special child. We also know that Azazel expresses interest in Mary in the season 4 episode "In the Beggining" and that when talking to Dean he notes that he's there "to choose the perfect parents, like your mommy....cause they're strong, they're pure, they eat their wheaties, my own little master race, they're 'ideal breeders'...(Dean looks at him). Oh get your mind out of the gutter. No one's breeding with me. Though Mary...man, I'd like to make an exception cause so far she's my favorite". To me that's a huge hint. What if Azazel, or some demon, on Azazel's orders, possesed Mary or John in order to concieve Sam? As this episode showed us, John wouldn't have even been needed since all a demon would have had to do was posses Mary and recreate inside of her. Following from that it would explain the detachment John always had towards Sam. I'm certainly not saying John didn't love Sam- there's no question given his overall actions throughout the years to protect Dean and Sam- however, it can't be denied there was always a rift between the two and that John always seemed at arms length. If either Mary or John couldn't remember conceiving Sam it could be that John suspected, after Mary's death, and his inquires into the nature of demons in the world, that there was somthing strange about his son. I mean he did tell Dean to kill Sam if he couldn't save him (something which has been mentioned again in passing during this season) because we assume he knew something of what Azazel was planning to use Sam for (although whether he knew about the seals or simply about the children opening the Gate to get Lillith free is unknown). Afterall, what kind of father asks his son to kill his other son? (and yes I am aware of the God, Michael and Lucifer metaphor here as well which is a whole other subject in SPN which others have already noted). From there, I'm brought back to episode 2 of season 3 where Ruby explains to Sam that all of his mother's old contacts and friends are dead because Azazel, or other demons killed them (just like Meg started doing to John's friends at the end of the first season). This has never been explained since it was brought up but If there was something strange about Sam and his birth, or after his birth for that matter (like Sam showing abilities), it isn't impossible that some of Mary and John's friends, hunters or non-hunters, would have also known something about it. Additionally, and just as importantly,it's worth referencing "In the Beggning" again where Azazel tells Dean that "I'm going to cover my tracks good" with reference to his overall end game.
Lastly Sam has shown, albiet nothing to the same degree, some of the same abilities as Jesse does in this episode. In episode 14 of season 1, for example, he moves a cabinet without even touching it to save Dean. In the season 1 finale Azazel, when torturing the Winchestors at the cabin, mocks Sam and suiggests that he telekeneticly grab the Colt to free himself and his brother. It was almost like Azazel wanted to see if Sam had developed any more abilities which where potentially stored within but not yet accessible. This makes me wonder if all the special children were all actually anti-christ's. After all, each of the special kids showed individual powers of which Jesse posseses in full and some of them, like Ava, began to develop more powers as they began to increase there usage of them (see the 2 part finale of season 2 where Ava learns to control other demons). It could be that that the demon blood fed to all of them by Azazel was simply the equivilent of breast feeding. Remember again that during the episode, "In the Beggining" Azazel notes that "demon blood is better than oval, team vitamins and minerals. It makes you big and strong!".
Anyways, those are just my thoughts. I could be wrong or I could be right on several of the theories. Only the end of this season will reveal the truth to which I'm happily waiting on pins and needles for.moreless