Shut Up, Dr. Phil was a great episode of Supernatural though it could have been slightly better. It was a great pleasure to see Charisma and James on screen together again. I enjoyed watching this episode because it had a good stand alone story with a larger arc in the background. I think certain elements of this could episode could have been sharper, but it was still very entertaining. The horror and gruesome scenes were pretty cool and the deaths were classic Supernatural. It would be great to get some one like Charisma or James to be a regular villain. I hope the season is not filled with filler stand alone episodes, I want to see more about what is going on in the larger picture. I look forward to watching the next episode!!!!!