Season 7 Episode 5

Shut Up, Dr. Phil

Aired Thursday 8:00 PM Oct 21, 2011 on The CW

Episode Fan Reviews (28)

Write A Review
out of 10
491 votes
  • A really enjoyable episode to watch.


    I really liked this episode, maybe being a Buffy fan helped a little in that aspect. Firstly, James Masters looks amazing, he has aged very well.

    The episode had a fair bit of humour to it, I laughed several times. It seemed like a more light hearted episode.

    Dean and Sam entered the house and just starting chanting to kill the witches, which seemed very clumsy. hence the score 9/10. I think in order to receive a 10/10, maybe they could have explained why the decided to spare the witches and planned or showed a little more research into the withces. I mean were the witches evil for over 800 years and should have been killed? Not enough background into the characters.

    I especially liked the end, it was a nice surprise element. I was expecting someone else to be reasonable, but when you find out who it was, it was great. It also had those excellent one liners Buffy was famous for.