User Score: 8585
Cara doesn't notice that she suddenly has a vase of Mediterranean hyacinths in her office. Which means they were already there. However, that means the siren's whole plan to trick Dean rests on the doctor having the one thing in her office that would be a very specific clue to its identity.
Cara's office is in the middle of a hospital, and has glass walls. But when she and Sam have sex, neither of them closes the Venetian blinds.
On-screen dialogue establishes that Young Dean and Sam arrive at Truman in November of 1997. However, in the flashback right after Sam says, "Barry had a hard time," a banner can be seen congratulating the seniors of 1997. Either the poster is seven months out of date, or it should refer to the current Class of 1998.
It's unlikely that Sam and Dean would be able to walk free from custody simply by way of Jay dropping the charges against them, particularly given that they would have been carrying firearms at the time of their arrest. Not only that, but presumably they would have been fingerprinted upon arrival at the station; surely that would have raised a few red flags, given that they were pronounced dead by the FBI after the explosion.
While Dean and Sam were at the Milton house they have left evidence of them being there like fingerprints on several objects. They both have their fingerprints in the police database, sooner or later the bodies will be found and evidence will point again to Winchester brothers.
When Sam starts to tell Dean the story about how Ruby saved his life, he is holding a towel to the cut he just stitched up, and his shirt sleeve is bloody from the wound. When the flashback takes a break, Sam hasn't moved from where he was sitting, but his shirt is spotless and there is no blood on his arm or towel stopping the flow.
When Dean and Sam leap out the window, the shot from inside shows the two brothers hitting the window simultaneously. However, when the camera cuts to the outside, Sam emerges first and Dean is considerably behind him.
When Sam is killing Samhain, his nose starts bleeding and the blood reaches his chin. However, in the next shot his face is clean and he starts bleeding all over again.
When Sam is researching in the hotel room in the beginning, he picks up the Goldthread to inspect it when he is flipping through books, and keeps it in his hand when Dean comes in. When he starts to tell Dean about the hex bag, one shot shows the Goldthread in his hand, and the very next, he picks it up from the hexbag, without having put it back.
When Sam and Dean ask the victim's wife how many razor blades were found she says "two on the floor, one in his stomach and was stuck in his throat." When you watch the scene where the victim spits out the razor blades, there are two on the floor but a third one is heard falling on the floor. So there should have been found at least three razor blades on the floor.
Trivia: When Sam tells Dean that Luke Wallace's and Jenny's deaths are linked to some spell ("Three blood sacrifices over three days...") he shows him a book. On the book an illustration can be seen. It's a Gustave Doré drawing (one of the most famous Dante's "Divina Commedia" illustrators), which represents Dante and Virgil in Hell, talking to the damned soul of the heretic Farinata Degli Uberti (see Dante's Inferno, canto 10).
Sam and Dean come out of their hotel room to find the Impala splattered and splotched, most likely by the astronaut boy who got no candy. However, when the brothers leave the house after having driven directly there from the hotel and the school in the middle of a crisis, it is perfectly clean.
When Dean and Sam are in the mill they hear a sound coming from the locker room. As Sam opens the locker a cat comes jumping out making Dean scream like a little girl. Just before the scene ends you see Dean and Sam leave the frame with Dean laughing.
In the scene when Sam and Dean are invited into the sheriff's office, for the first time. Sam gets out of his chair and begins adjusting his shirt collar. But when the shot changes his hands are down to his side.
For some reason the closed caption says that Waylon Jenning's Slow Rollin' Low is playing in the police station when Dean and Sam go into the sheriff's office. No such music is playing.
Autopsies are suppose to be recorded when doing the procedure. The doctor did not record himself, instead he was talking with Sam and Dean.
When Sam picked the lock to enter Lucy's place, the lock knob above the handle didn't turn.
When Dean says this line after taking the ribbon out of his pocket to show Sam in the bar after his fight with Dracula: "This, I uh, pulled it off during the fight" his lips don't move, and the volume is different from the rest of his line, you can clearly tell this line was added in post as a voiceover.
When the brothers arrive in town the first night, there's a crescent moon in the sky. However, the second night when the werewolf strikes, the moon is full. The moon doesn't change phases that fast from crescent to full in a single night.
The sign outside the Montgomery house reads "The Montgomery's," with an incorrectly used apostrophe.
User Score: 8585
User Score: 653
User Score: 351
User Score: 313
User Score: 262
User Score: 232
User Score: 201
User Score: 186
User Score: 176
User Score: 156
User Score: 138
User Score: 135
User Score: 129
User Score: 129
User Score: 113
User Score: 107
User Score: 104
User Score: 97
User Score: 96
User Score: 89
dysfuntional families, Supernatural, demonic resurrection, absent parent, supernatural forces