This is shaping up to be the perfect mytharc
10
I think they hit on just the right story arc. Now that they have given me something more fun and simple, I realize I was really ready for something more fun and simple (though I loved the previous seasons.) It flows organically out of the first seven seasons without a single hitch or stutter. It's just pared down to a more straightforward story. The good guys and the bad guys racing against each other, trying to outmaneuver each other, chasing the same thing, using characters and artefacts and places that were already in play. And we have personal stories from the characters, how Purgatory has affected them, to add substance to the mix.
Another thing that adds substance to the fun and games with Crowley is the moral dilemmas. I have always loved this about Supernatural, how there are no easy answers, there are no clearcut choices between good and evil, right and wrong. There are only tough decisions, and consequences to bear.
The boys take turns playing Jiminy Cricket, and at the moment Sam is wearing the tiny tophat. Dean has come back from Purgatory much more ruthless. But the thing is, he has a point, in a Spockian "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few or the one" kind of way. Dean is willing to sacrifice Kevin's mom, but if it means canning all demons forever, countless lives will be saved. On the other hand, sacrificing other people's loved ones is not the same as sacrificing your own. Dean would never sacrifice Sam, so Kevin's decision to flee with his mother is completely understandable. Dean would do the same, except he would probably gank whoever had tried to sacrifice Sam rather than run.
It was movingly clear what a toll a lifetime of these tough decisions have had on the boys when Dean says "What's one more nightmare, right?" You can feel the soul-deep weariness on both of them. But the good thing is, even when they make the wrong decision, there is redemption. They get Hell for it for a while, both literally and figuratively, but they find ways of making amends and forgiving each other in the end. As now it would seem Dean is on his way to forgiving Cas.
In the end, Kevin's mom survived, though catatonic. I hope she recovers, because she's a great character. I was really worried in the beginning though. One of the female character cliches I don't like is when they force the male characters into taking them along on a mission, instead of being naturally included on the team because they have skills that will help. The cliche then usually goes on to show the female character being an impediment, getting taken hostage because she refused to listen to the men and stay in the car, Tardis, or whatever, and then doing some token helpful act. Jo in No Exit and Chrissie in Adventures in Babysitting are classic examples of this cliche. I think we're supposed to think it's spunky when they do something like burn all the clues to force the man to bring them along, but to me it's really just obnoxious. Even if she committed the clues to memory, that can never replace having the actual clues, so she's just hindering the rescue of her father and Sam rather than helping. And then everyone acted like she had saved the day when she was the one who messed up the day in the first place. Dean had it well in hand before she got taken hostage. (Interestingly, there are a lot of gender role reversals on the series Chuck, and this cliche was applied to Morgan. I didn't like it there either.)
So I was very relieved when the cliche didn't play out that way. Kevin's mom was a cool character who never got in the way, proved to be a tough cookie, and what she lacked in fighting abilities or supernatural gifts, she amply made up for with courageous self-sacrifice. She was very human in her fear, but there was steely resolve under it, and that combination made her a very likeable character.
Carver said this season would be like a quest, and it would be personal, and so far it looks like they're really going to deliver on that.