We're moving Forums to the Community pages. Click here for more information and updates.


Season 11 Episode 4

To Betray or Not to Betray

Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM Oct 06, 2005 on CBS
out of 10
User Rating
54 votes

By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

In a twisted "reward" challenge, four players are sent out for a picnic lunch in the Mayan ruins as their tribemates are shuffled up with members of the opposing tribe. Thus, Yaxha is now composed of four former Nakum members and only three Yaxha members, and the current Nakum is made up of four of each tribe. Upon arriving home from their picnic, Gary, Amy, Judd, and Margaret are shocked to find out about the switch, and all of the survivors scramble to find a new alliance. Although most are drawn on former tribal lines, Judd fits in better with Stephenie and Jamie, and quietly makes a pact with them to turn on his old tribemates. Nakum loses the Immunity Challenge, and at Tribal Council, Judd is forced to act on his new alliance, doing so by being the swing vote and eliminating Brooke from the game.moreless

Watch Full Episode

Your Autoplay Preference: On | Off

Who was the Episode MVP ?

No results found.
No results found.
No results found.
  • Brooke! You will be missed! :'(

    Very sad elimination this time! Brooke was my faovrite up to this point, but I suppose I must now cheer for Amy and Danni. I really took a big liking to Amy in this episode! She got some more air time, and her personality came through, and I really enjoyed it!

    The Tribal Swap was GREAT!!! Amazing to witness how it happened! They had to vote for the person who was the most 'living and breathing Yaxha/Nakum' and the rest got swappeed!!

    The new tribe dynamics should be interesting! I love swaps, as they tend to result in a lot more drama and intrigue!

    However, Judd is now my least favourite after betraying his alliance, and especially Brooke. Don't like the guy at all. I also don't like KLydia, Gary or Rafe, in all honesty, and Brian too. Everyone else is reasonably likeable, though!

    Can't wait to see what will happen netx! This season got really interesting after this one!moreless
  • Okay, once again people I like are voted out.

    Totally didn't want the mix!

    Judd. Let me describe you. Arrogant, cocky, rude, mean, obnoxious, dumb and traitor. I can't stand him! He just thinks he's the best. I know Survivor and I know arrogance does not take you anywhere. You'll pay eventually. I never liked Jamie. He's like Judd. Arrogant and cocky. Stephanie is desperate. She will do ANYTHING to have that money. I wouldn't be surprised if she turned against her tribe mates. Not at all.

    Lydia is kind of annoying. And the thing is she's becoming cocky and too much confident. She's such a liability! I really like Margaret and Cindy, and I hope they will manage to stay in the game. About the other tribe, I really like Danni, Blake, Bobby and Brandon. I think they will stick with their former tribe.

    About Gary. What's up with hiding your true identity?! Danni has clearly figured him out, and he continues to deny it. It's a lot worse to hide it than to reveal it. Let's see what happens in the next episode ;)moreless
  • Silly episode IMO!

    Some episodes of Survivor are great

    Some not so great

    Some are just very awesome

    Some are just plain dumb

    Some are one of my favorite episodes

    Some are also can be just very unforgiven

    There are good ones as well as bad ones

    Though you have to have a bad person with good team

    Or a good person with a bad team

    It ain't the first nor will it be the last time at all!
Jeff Probst

Jeff Probst


Cindy Hall

Cindy Hall

Herself (Season 11)

Danni Boatwright

Danni Boatwright

Herself (Season 11)

Gary Hogeboom

Gary Hogeboom

Himself (Season 11)

Jamie Newton

Jamie Newton

Himself (Season 11)

Judd Sergeant

Judd Sergeant

Himself (Season 11)

Featured Episode Clip

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions