Sheen is definitely smarter. I discussed this in a forum on idreamofjimmy.com a while ago, and I don't feel like re-typing all that, so I'll just copy and paste.
"I think Carl is dumber, because I'm ridiculously loyal to Sheen!
Plus, Sheen seems to be more distracted than stupid. He has a bit more street/life smarts than Carl does. Like in CJHS, when Carl is all like, "If you guys go on a date, can I come? Maybe we could play board games and talk and laugh..." and Jimmy and Sheen share a look that sort of says "How stupid Is he?" And in The Tomorrow Boys, when Sheen realizes that they all really hurt Libby's feelings by destroying her stuff, and spends eight straight hours writing a 37-chapter apology (how sweet was that?).
Also, Sheen's brain is larger than Carl's, as we know from The Junkman Cometh. Sheen also has a pretty good memory (for random useless information anyway). Also, Sheen's random statements/kind nature indirectly save the day way more than Carl. In LoV, the only reason anybody got saved at all is because Sheen befriended Tee. In MBFSW, he called that monkey squad. In JTPH, he tells Timmy to use his giant teeth (which ended up being the only way to open the box). There's more, I know, but I can't remember all of them at this moment.
In conclusion, Sheen rocks, all day, everyday, forever. Rock on, Sheen!"
Is that argument convincing enough?
You must be registered and logged in to post a message.