While the progress in Leonard and Penny's relationship is a reason to watch, Sheldon's side-plot is very amusing, suspenseful and fascinating. For how silly and simple it is, I loved it. And the ending, to find out what he was actually doing in that secret room of his, was great.
Even though I'm happy that Leonard and Penny are back together, Leonard is turning into a huge control freak panicking over Penny working with someone else and telling her what to text. I found this part of the episode boring and rather uncomfortable. But the other part of the episode with Sheldon, Raj and Howard was brilliant as Sheldon seems to be getting less funny every episode and then he pranks Howard and Raj in the best moment in series 6. I hope the writers will realise that you don't need Amy and Bernadette for a good episode
the anti Amy and Bernadette reviewers about this episode !
Yes, the primary emphasis is on the 4 guys and Penny but the ONLY reason this show is the highest rated comedy in the States is that it appeals to everyone, NOT just geeks.
I reckon the show would have run out of steam around mid third season without the appearance of relationships for the cast. Let's face it, nerdiness can only appeal for just so long !
Anyway, to this episode and the "L" word.
At last, Penny finally managed to blurt out what we all knew and give poor Leonard (massively intelligent but unable to notice he's being hit on) a huge confidence boost.
Unfortunately for Penny, I fear this might lead to him trying out his new found "studliness", when he finally realises what Alex is actually saying to him.
As a "Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy" and "X-Files" fan, I too was thrown by the "43" on the board for the same reason as Howard and Raj (the X-Files reference is that Fox Mulders apartment number was also "42" in an homage to "Hitchhikers").
I also thought it might be a Sheldon experiment to see how many days it would take 'till the gang tried to find out what he was doing.
Hackey Sack, I did NOT expect. Well done the writers for the trickery !
My only issue (let's face it, it wouldn't be me if I didn't have one), is the timescale that Sheldon managed to produce the fake video. It looked like Howard and Raj had barely fitted the camera (loved the "million dollar camera, 10 dollar lock" reference) and Sheldon had the vid ready.
Realistically, I don't care as Howard and Raj are NEVER going to suffer from constipation again, after Sheldon dropped the multi-limbed creature on the laptop.
Certainly one of the better episodes but I see trouble ahead for Leonard, when Penny hits "jealous" mode and possibly tries to chop off his dangly bits.
P.S. Bart Simpson is still a kid because IT'S A CARTOON and he doesn't need to evolve and Scrubs died a natural death when Zack Braff wanted to go on to other things and as he was the main character, the show had nowhere to go.
Boy did this episode hit the nail on the head. It was simply a great episode very much in the vein of earlier seasons. They didn't deal that much in the male/female relationships but did use Penny's and Leonard's to great effect. But it was funny to see Leonard act so anal and then to see him get hit on by Alex while being completely obtuse to what she was doing. That seems a sure thing for future development and it will be fun to see how the Penny/Alex/Leonard thing plays out. In my opinion Alex is cuter than Penny and probably wouldn't present Leonard with so many problems. But then the other plot line in this episode, Sheldon down in his secret room, was hilarious. I really laughed hard near the end when they saw Sheldon get attacked by a creature from his wormhole! Hilarious to watch Raj and Howard freak out and see Sheldon come walking up behind them. It was also interesting to see Ryan Cartwright in his small role and he was a rather cool guy compared to Gary on Alphas.
I agree to 100% with srthakran and angeland8's posts. This was a good "old school" episode based on nerdy interactions, social incompetence and some (but only some) relationship issues. Recent episodes where too focused on relationship and girl problems that clearly took some of the edge away from the show.
The initial setup of the how based on nerdiness, socially weird behavior and this Penny-Howard thing was brilliant. Supporting acts without need being slowly propped up to main characters (Amy, Berndette or Stuart) did not do much good.
Don't get me wrong, Amy's character has some form of nerdiness on her own but the girlfriend problems (funny once, ok twice but terrible afterwards) just don't fit all too well with Sheldon...
Now some people may claim that characters "have to evolve" over time but that is just not true for every show! Have you ever wondered why Bart Simpson is still in school or why Scrubs failed after too much "evolution"?
It was a decent episode, helped as ever by the absence of Amy & Bernadette that otherwise suck so much life out of the show, but seeing all the 9.x/10.0 reviews first it's such an anticlimax to have an episode that is good without being outstanding.
Plus points: good interactions between Howard and Raj, the Sheldon mystery and Sheldon's universal explorations, some sharp lines: "I didn't even know you were here", for example. Minus: the scripts are still flagging in places - Leonard's insecurity.
Still a pretty good episode, and a definite bounce back after last week's snore-fest.
In a very long time big bang theory has got what it deserves, an episode without bernadette and amy farrah fowler.. this is what the show must be about.. those sick characters are so irritating that i almost lost faith in the show.