Lives are saved and lives are lost as The Man's clients try to complete their tasks. Meanwhile, The Man completes his task and gets what he asked for, and Doris makes a wish of her own.
Paths start to intertwine between clients as Conner finds a lost person, Henry meets a man who knows of a higher power, and Melody meets someone who could make her life worth living. Meanwhile, Doris continues to write down what The Man is thinking as he helps one of his clients.moreless
As The Man's clients grow restless, he begins to question human nature. At the same time, he learns what he will have to do to get his own wish fulfilled.
The Man continues his dealmaking, and finds a client who wants something that actually shocks him. Meanwhile, Melody demands to know what happened to her and Doris agrees to help The Man in return for answers.
New clients seek out The Man, who has moved to a new diner. However, he discovers that he can't escape his past.