This episode is much better than the first part except the flashbacks which still seemed forced in, but the fake ones were quite good, though Will lying about all his close personal famous friends went on far too long.
The unexpected twist that she chose Carlton and then the twist at the end where it turns out she was a kleptomaniac (the only person to go on a date with Carlton turns out to be mentally deranged) were very good parts in the episode.
The whole Cinderella thing was fairly funny but absurd and doesn’t really work with the show’s context.
Will’s scary story is a great way to end the episode and overall, this is one episode that I don’t regret watching.