A judge and the Deputy Commissioner ask Toby, Michelle and Dev to look into Becker, who may be involved in criminal activity.
Toby goes undercover in prison when a man with no criminal record walks into court and confesses to having murdered a man.
Toby experiences memory loss after being drugged and is accused of participating in an armed-kidnapping incident.
The team must contend with a series of secrets when investigating the death of a billionaire playboy. Meanwhile, Tia wants to learn about Toby's family and his past.
Oz's neighbor is murdered, and the investigation reveals that the victim was involved in a legendary coin heist.
With municipal elections upcoming, Becker reopens an unsolved three-year old murder investigation. With Toby's gift, he hopes to be able to convict Mayoral candidate Greg Turner, a man he is convinced committed the crime during the last election cycle.
A cooking-show contestant is poisoned on live TV. Sandy has some big news for Oz.
Toby is forced to deal with a mentally unstable suspect during the IIB investigation of a murdered psychiatrist. Meanwhile, Oz panics after Tia arranges for the newspaper's restaurant critic to dine at his establishment.
The IIB investigates when Dev's friend, a computer game developer, is found murdered in his office on the day his latest game is released.
The team investigates the death of an investment expert who was killed during a magic stunt gone wrong. Meanwhile, Toby's secret is threatened due to Becker's scrutiny of him.
Reports of corruption at a dance academy lead to the kidnapping of the prima ballerina just days before an overseas tour.
The team investigates when $200,000, thought to be in police custody, tumbles from the ceiling of a college football team's dressing room. Meanwhile, the a new IIB leader is appointed.
In the fifth-season opener, Toby and Dev track a serial killer who leaves live snakes with his victims, a signature move that resembles the work of a criminal Michelle may have wrongly incarcerated.