The Simpsons

Season 11 Episode 3

Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner

Aired Sunday 8:00 PM Oct 24, 1999 on FOX
out of 10
User Rating
172 votes

By Users

Episode Summary

With Lisa's journalistic help Homer begins a new endeavor as food critic for the Springfield Shopper. Homer loves everything he eats, but at the advice of other food critics, he starts giving bad reviews to the ire of Lisa and local restaurant owners who conspire against him in a deadly plot.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

No results found.
No results found.
  • Comedy of Error

    I love this episode of the Simpsons. It has food, father and daughter bonding, Ed Asner, and so much more. I think it was a terrific episode, but I did find one error. When Homer rights his first review (without Lisa) and he doesn't have the letter 'e' I found an error later on. When the Editor reads the review he says all the things Homer tried to spell without the letter 'e' but yet he ends his review with "screw flanders" which has 2 'e's in it. Otherwise terrific episode. My favorite of this season. Hope this show lasts forever.moreless
  • Very funny epsiode.

    Homer is chaperoning a field trip to the Springfield Shopper. While there, he gets a job as a food critic. However, Lisa writes the column for him. One day at a critics convention, the other newspaper critics tell him his reviews don't have to be all taht nice. So he starts writing (or, Lisa starts writing)mean reviews about all the restaurants. Soon, the restaurant owners all plan to kill Homer at a food festival by putting poison in the food. Bart overhears them, and tells Marge right away. Homer is saved, and Him and Lisa make up.

    This was a very funny episode. I loved Homer swearing at the ambulance, Homer's line"hmm... pointless nostalgia, the headline from the day Homer was born that read:Unusually large ugly baby born, and The Sea Captain putting up Homer's bad review to cover up the Health inspector's note.

    Overall Garde:A++/95%moreless
  • I Keel You

    Homer becomes a critic of food with the help of Lisa {who writes his reviews for him}. But after meeting some other critics for different things, they tell him he doesn't have to be nice all the time. So instead, Homer becomes too mean. Lisa can't stand this and so she quits working with him as his partner.

    Some restaurant owners in Springfield are angered by Homer's reviews. So they all plot to murder him at a Taste of Springfield festival, with poison.

    Bart hears of this and tells Marge and Lisa. Lisa finds Homer and saves him. Homer and Lisa reconcile after their fight.

    A typical Homer gets a job, but wait- this one's funny! With a good plot that doesn't involve fully on one Simpson {which is always nice and a plus for the current show}.moreless
  • Homer becomes a food critic, and gets himself into some big trouble.

    This episode has to be in the top 3 episodes of season 11 because it is just hilarious. Maybe I would even include it in my favorite episode pile. It just delivered great jokes all throughout the episode, and it did not disappoint. For example when Luigi says:

    Luigi: He gave mya restaurant a bad review. So one of my friends put a horse head in his bed. He ate the horse head and gave it a bad review! This is just a sample of the great hunor in this episode. Very well written on the writers part. I tip my hat to them. Amoreless
  • Guess Who's coming to critized dinner is the third episode of the 11th season, and it pays off really well.

    "I like pizza, i like bagel, i like hotdog with mustard and cheese, i could eat eggplant, i could even eat a baby deer, lalalalala, whos the baby deer on the lollipop"

    It just suprising how they made this material and still is hilarious. The third episode, Guess Who's Coming to Critized Dinner is a funny episode that talks about critics. After Homer mistakenly drive Lisa, Millhouse, Bart and Nelson to the Zoo, they went to the Springfield Chopper, a local newspaper station. Homer dosed off and got a job for Food Critic. His first attempt on making a 500 page sampler review didn't work that well, as he required assistance from Lisa, who made a positive and good review making his review on the newspaper.The typewriter has no "e" key, so it turns out to be a pretty bad review. Also in it, he makes threatening statements to the U.N. and repeats the phrase, "Screw Flanders." Together, Homer and Lisa teams up and created every positive review for every restaurant in Springfield. After the critics give him advice to write a negative review, Lisa doesn't like his style so she leaves him and his review. All of the restaurants join together in a consipary to kill Homer by a 1 million calariy filled with poison and accidently antidote sweet dessert, at the taste of Springfield. Bart overhears the convestration at the festivial and tells Marge and Lisa about the deadly pasty. At the end, Lisa tells Homer "its low fat" and the police arrested the culpit.

    This is the first episode in this season, where Lisa and Homer teams up together, its just nice to see that. I wish most episodes would do that, making it a comfortable experieneced for everyone. The humour in this episode is historial, the first evidence is where Homer is in his car swearing at the amublance and its just laugh out loud. Its just funny to see a polar bear riding on a moose in the sequence in the zoo. Gil is back in this episode in a short part and he is just hilarious, voiced by Dan Castalla. And Homer in the bathroom, classic. "Still not clean" Theres amounts of gags, quotes and allusions in this episodes. One of the Allusions were When Homer says, "we don't need no stinkin' E," this is a reference to a line from The Treasure of Sierra Madre, which goes "We don't need no stinkin' badges." and a humourous reference to the Godfather (where a character finds a dead horse's head in their bed.

    Overall, Guess Who's Coming to Critized Dinner is funny but does gives you a lesson, that critics always get critized by the public. The ending of this episode is hilarious, getting chased by a mob and credits roll. This is a recommended watch for any Simpsons fans and people tunning in.moreless
Harry Shearer

Harry Shearer

Mr. Burns, Ned Flanders, Principal Skinner, Waylon Smithers, Kent Brockman, and others

Dan Castellaneta

Dan Castellaneta

Homer Simpson, Grampa Simpson, Barney Gumble, Krusty the Clown, Groundskeeper Willie, and others

Nancy Cartwright

Nancy Cartwright

Bart Simpson, Nelson Muntz, Ralph Wiggum, Todd Flanders, and others

Yeardley Smith

Yeardley Smith

Lisa Simpson

Hank Azaria

Hank Azaria

Apu Nahasapeemapetilon, Moe Szyslak, Chief Wiggum, Comic Book Guy, Lou, and others

Julie Kavner

Julie Kavner

Marge Simpson, Patty Bouvier, and Selma Bouvier

Edward Asner

Edward Asner


Guest Star

Karl Wiedergott

Karl Wiedergott

Additional Voices

Recurring Role

Pamela Hayden

Pamela Hayden

Milhouse Van Houten, Rod Flanders, Jimbo Jones, and others

Recurring Role

Tress MacNeille

Tress MacNeille

Agnes Skinner, Brandine Del Roy, Dolph and others

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions


  • TRIVIA (2)

    • When Homer looks up the headline from the day he was born the "Unusually large, ugly baby born" is actually Homer, he just doesn't realize it.

    • In the couch gag where Marge wipes Matt Groening's signature off the carpet and a caricature of Matt Groening comes back to rewrite it, Groening was signing the scene with his right hand. In real life, Matt Groening is left-handed.

  • QUOTES (30)

    • Bart: There's that awful script from The Cable Guy.
      Homer: Let me see that. Stupid script! Nearly wrecked Jim Carrey's career! (Starts ripping up the script and then sees everyone looking at him) What?

    • Editor: You know, Homer, we need someone like you. Someone who doesn't immediately "poo-poo" everything he eats.
      Homer: Nah, usually takes me a few hours.

    • Homer: So come to The Legless Frog if you want to get sick and die and leave a big garlicky corpse. PS, parking was ample.
      Lisa: Dad, you're being cruel for no reason! What will people think?
      Homer: People will think what I tell them to think when you tell me what to tell them to think!
      Lisa: Not anymore! I don't want to be partners with a man who thinks like that!

    • Homer: This pea soup is as weak as the acting and nowhere near as hammy.
      Lisa: Dad, that's so mean!
      Homer: The other critics told me to be mean, and you should always give in to peer pressure.
      Lisa: But what if someone bad tells me to --
      Homer: Always.

    • (At the Taste of Springfield Festival)
      Marge: Homie, my womens' intuition is acting up. Something bad is going to happen if you go in there.
      Homer: Oh, Marge, something bad usually happens when I go in anywhere.
      (He steps in a puddle, then a frisbee hits him, then a bat bites him)
      Homer: A bat, that's a new one.

    • Homer: This gets my lowest rating ever. Seven thumbs up.

    • Captain McCallister: (talking about Homer) I'm surprised he doesn't just give it up and go for sweatpants.
      Akira: He says the crotch wears out too fast.
      Captain McCallister: Yar! That's going to replace the whale in my nightmares.

    • Editor: Homer what gives with this review? You say the salad tastes like bark and the potatoes were very grrrrrrr. This reads like it was written by a dog.
      Homer: Are you crazy? A dog can't type!…Unfortunately.

    • Homer: Uh not bad. If Lasagna is Italian for pile of puke!
      Italian Chef: Ahhhh…I choppa you good!
      (Swings at Homer with a knife.)
      Homer: Well, I hope you cut me better than you did these string beans!…Hmm, I seem to be missing part of my ear...Touché!

    • Homer: Really, the only word to describe it is (drools)
      Lisa: Hmm. What's the English equivalent for (drools) I'd say ... transcendent.
      Homer: How about groin-grabbingly transcendent?
      Lisa: Uh ... I don't think so.

    • Homer: Well, what do you think?
      Editor: This is a joke, right? I mean this is the stupidest thing I've ever read!
      Homer: What's wrong with it?
      Editor: You keep using words like "Pasghetti" and "Momatoes" You make numerous threatening references to the UN and at the end you repeat the words "Screw Flanders" over and over again.

    • Homer: (voice on tape singing)
      I work hard for the money
      So hard for the money
      Oh, I something, something money,
      Come on give me lots of honey
      Mr. Burns: Well, there's an employee, Smithers. A smile on his lips and a song in his heart. Promote him.

    • Milhouse: I spy with my little eye, something beginning with D.
      Nelson: Dingus!
      (Nelson smacks Milhouse in the head)
      Homer: God bless you, Nelson Muntz.
      Nelson: I'm no hero. I just like to hit people on the head.

    • Homer: (Asking Santa's Little Helper to help him out with a word to describe the food) Come on, help me out here.
      Santa's Little Helper: Ruff!
      Homer: Rough? I don't know, you've been pitching that all night.
      Santa's Little Helper: Chewy?
      Homer: Chewy! That's inspired!

    • (counting what is supposed to be a 500-word review)
      Lisa: 497, 498 words.
      Homer: How about "Screw Flanders"?
      Lisa: (Typing) Bon appetit.
      Homer: Eh, both good.

    • Marge: Homer, you do know the E is broken on that typewriter.
      Homer: We don't need no stinkin' E! Let's see... Restaurant Review... No! Eatery Evaluation! No! Food Box! Go or No Go by Homer... no, Earl... no... Bill Simpson!

    • Restauranteur: Well I say we ban Homer from our restaurants.
      Akira: No, that would be impolite. I say we kill him!

    • Captain McCallister: Argh, well I've had it with Homer. His bad reviews are sinking our businesses.
      Akira: Then why did you put yours in the window?
      Captain McCallister: Argh, it covered up the "D" from the Health Inspector.

    • Homer: Stop the presses!
      (The presses stop. Homer puts his food article on the belt)
      Homer: Ok, start the presses!
      Press Manager: (angrily) That takes four hours!
      Homer: Whatever, I'll be at Moe's.

    • Theatre Critic: The only bad review you gave was to a slice of pizza you found under the couch.
      Homer: It lost some points because it had a hot wheel on it.

    • TV Critic: Nine thumbs up!?!? What the hell is that!?

    • Nelson: Your old man has an awesome nose.
      Bart: Oh, that's nothing, he can hear pudding!

    • Marge: Only your father could take a part-time job at a small-town paper and wind up the target of international assassins.

    • Homer: (singing to the tune of "I Feel Pretty") I like pizza, I like bagels, I like hot dogs with mustard and beer...
      Editor: I get the picture.
      Homer: I'll eat eggplant, I could even eat a baby deer! La-la-la-la-la-la-la-la, who's that baby deer on the lawn there?
      Editor: Enough already!
      Homer: Sorry.

    • Homer: I don't want anyone to know that I am the food critic.
      Maude: Ned, Homer's the food critic, pass it on.

    • Bart: Come to think of it, I haven't seen Uter since the last field trip.
      Principal Skinner: Uter, I don't remember any Uter, Uter what a funny name.

    • Springfield Shopper Woman: Here at the Springfield Shopper we use a percentage of recycled paper.
      Lisa: What percent?
      Springfield Shopper Woman: Zero. (Pause) What!? Zero's a percent.

    • Homer: They're paying me to eat!
      Bart: Now if they paid you to scratch your butt, you'd be on Easy Street.

    • Restaurant Owner: You're going to kill him with a pastry? I've seen this man eat a bowl of change!

    • Homer: Marge, I'm sorry, but your cooking's only got two moves, shake and bake.
      Marge: You like Shake 'N' Bake. You used to put it in your coffee.

  • NOTES (1)

    • Blackboard Joke: I am not the last Don.
      Couch Gag: The family sits on the couch as usual. Marge notices the name "Matt Groening" scrawled on the carpet and wipes it off. Matt Groening, decked out in one of his trademark Hawaiian shirts, runs in and re-autographs the scene.


    • West Side Story
      The song that Homer sings about food is an allusion to the song "I Feel Pretty" from West Side Story.

    • Tour Guide: The paper was founded by Johnny Newspaperseed...
      This is a reference to the American Folklore character of Johnny Appleseed, which was also made into a Disney cartoon.

    • MiseryThe typewriter with no "E" alludes to the Stephen King movie/novel Misery, where the antagonist is forced to use a typewriter without an "E".

    • Moby Dick
      Homer writes a review of The Frying Dutchman with the headline "Thar, She Blows." This is a line from Herman Melville's novel Moby Dick. It's likely that Lisa came up with the headline; Homer isn't exactly the literary type.

    • The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
      When Homer says, "We don't need no stinkin' E," this is a reference to a line from the 1948 film The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, which goes "We don't need no stinkin' badges."

    • Lisa: We ate at Paté LaBelle last week.
      The restaurant's name is a play on the name of well-known R&B singer Patti LaBelle.

    • Mimi the Food Critic: Why make 31 flavors when you can't get vanilla right?
      An unflattering reference to Baskin Robbins ice cream. Their slogan is 31 Flavors.

    • Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
      The title of this episode is a play on the title of the 1967 film Guess Who's Coming to Dinner, starring Spencer Tracy, Katherine Hepburn and Sidney Poitier.

    • Luigi: He gave me a bad review. My friend put a horse head in his bed, and he ate it and gave it a bad review.
      This is a reference to The Godfather, when a character wakes up and sees a horse's head in his bed.