Aside from question over the names of the neigbours Wingate or Moran (see notes), there is one continuity error. Randy Boone is shown leaning against a door and starts to move. The camera switches to a different angle and he is still and begins to move again.
It was a great addition to the episode, but the song Randy sings, "I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry", wasn't written until 1949 by Hank Williams. Of course, The Virginian was set in the late 1800's.
Judge Garth's gun branded with an "S" for Shiloh changes at the end of the episode.
When first seen, when the cowhand borrows it to put down a steer with a broken leg, it is a solid white "S" on black grips. Later, the replacement gun also has a solid white "S" on black grips. At the end of the episode, the "S" has a black outline and the white color is not as bright.