Clearly this episode was meant as a showcase for Gillian Anderson, and she did very well with what she had. Writer Kim Newton gave her some wonderful scenes, such as her decision to keep Kevin with her rather than send him to a shelter, her conversation with Owen Jarvis, her goodbye to Mulder (further evidence that she can no longer confide in him--she never even tells him where she is going), and of course her final scene: "I'm afraid God is speaking, and no one is listening." Anderson displayed again her ability to bring a luminous intensity to the quietest word and gesture. She can personalize the smallest, most routine moment of an investigation without trivializing it or "domesticating" it.
Duchovny, however, never managed to find a way to show us a skeptical Mulder who was still Mulder. This is one of the few times I have seen him portray Mulder when it looked more like David Duchovny than Mulder onscreen. Some of this can be laid at the feet of Kim Newton's inability to delineate a credible doubting Mulder: the most unbelievable line I have heard this season is Mulder saying, "How is that possible?" Mulder is asking this? Mulder, who constantly pulls explanations out of thin air?
I was dumbfounded by the utter lack of mourning when the mother died. Kevin tried desperately to save her, then merely expressed regret at her death, as if he had lost a baseball game. Even the incarcerated father does not even mention the woman who died trying to save her son. A loving mother dies in a fight with the devil and nobody cares! This emotional refrigeration just wiped out my involvement in the story.
Why does Kevin Kryder exhibit the stigmata at all? If you're one of the faithful who accept these marks as signs of sanctified faith, then you're bound to be troubled by the fact that at no time during the episode does Kevin make any profession of faith of any kind. He does not even pray in moments of stress. This is what happens when you use a symbol and ignore what it signifies. Stigmata in themselves mean nothing; they are supposed to mark out the faithful among us as chosen witnesses of God. Strip a symbol of its meaning and you have an empty token. Since Kevin is not a child of faith, what is he? A victim of God? His condition becomes a mere curiosity. His hands carry less significance than the Millenium Man's, which can generate enough heat to bend steel.
If, on the other hand, you're a skeptic who does not believe in miracles, you're left with no explanation at all advanced for the bleeding wounds--hysteria? self-inflicted wounds? psychosomatic trauma? Anything? Where is our famous Oxford-trained psychologist, Fox Mulder? Why isn't he coming up with explanations?
This episode did not scare me. Chris Carter is fond of saying that something is only as scary as it is real; by extension, this means that if it could happen to you or me, it's scary. I don't know about you, but I'm unlikely to wake up anytime soon with the marks of divine favor on my hands.
The script was weak and the introduction of Scully's faith built on too flimsy a foundation. Gillian Anderson's excellent work is the one saving grace (religious joke) of this otherwise below average episode.
|
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
|
User Score: 501
User Score: 2170
User Score: 1925
User Score: 1641
User Score: 491
User Score: 340
User Score: 260
User Score: 243
User Score: 200
User Score: 190
CBS Entertainment | About TV.com | About CBS Interactive | Jobs | Advertise
© CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Ad Choice | Terms of Use
