Mulder goes to Massachusetts, to investigate reports of UFO activity and finds a town cowed by cockroach attacks. Mulder confronts artificial roaches, a factory making fuel out of dung, and an attractive entomologist named Bambi. Scully, worried about Mulder, gets caught up in a fleeing crowd and winds up covered in dung with Mulder.
The episode is obviously a parody, and is filled with moments both brilliant and farcical. Fans will be hurling one-liners culled from this episode at one another for a long time to come. But these moments, charming as they are taken individually, add up to less than a whole.
"War of the Coprophages" reads like a fanfic, a story written by a fan about his or her favorite show. As such it incorporates some of the worst excesses of that genre: indulgent self-references, sophomoric humor, and shallow characterization. Writer Darin Morgan leaves no pun unturned, no sight gag ignored. He cannot resist the sly in-joke, and there are several times when he should. If he cannot dazzle us with brilliance and subtlety, he is not above bathroom humor. Or insult: Mulder's parting remark to Scully, "You smell bad", is just mean-spirited. We got the return of Scully's dog, we got the personal phone calls in the middle of the night, we got David Duchovny wandering around in various states of undress, and we got Scully acting jealous. Is this "The X- Files" or a Doris Day/Rock Hudson movie?
The trouble with "Coprophages" was only partly with the individual elements of the story: much of the problem was the overall tone. There is a fine and dangerous line between black humor and sophomoric smirking. The tongue-in-cheek approach is funny once, amusing twice, and tedious a third time.
This is no denigration of Darin Morgan's talent: his genius lies in setting up scenes where the payoff is either a visual cue. Scully scavenging "bug" candy in the ruins of the store was a very clever reference to the actual bug she ate in Humbug. And I think we all enjoyed the "cockroach" that crawled across our screens at home. : )
Overall, this episode threw in everything including the bathroom sink, yet fails to achieve a coherent line. But seeing a casual Scully at home made up for my lack of interest in the plot. Frankly, I would have prefered just an hour at home with Scully as she goes about her daily routine. lol
|
Monday
No results found.
Tuesday
No results found.
Wednesday
No results found.
|
User Score: 501
User Score: 2170
User Score: 1925
User Score: 1641
User Score: 491
User Score: 340
User Score: 260
User Score: 243
User Score: 200
User Score: 190
CBS Entertainment | About TV.com | About CBS Interactive | Jobs | Advertise
© CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Ad Choice | Terms of Use
