Sarah meets a homeless man who gives her a rock. She discovers that once he was a conductor of the Metropolitan Opera. Her recording deal falls through when the recording company is shut down for tax fraud. Tony is worried that this will mean that Sarah won't want anything else with him. Spencer comes back and embarrasses himself in the bar so he and Sarah are even. Maguire's place runs out of power, so he stays with Sarah until Romy comes back. Sarah ends up having Thanksgiving dinner at her place with the four men in her life: the homeless, Tony, Maguire and Spencer. Sarah tells Tony and Spencer that they'll just be friends to her, the homeless man leaves her, and she finally kisses Maguire.