Since the popular theory right now is that Season 5 will be Heroes vs Villains, I thought it would be cool to try and spectulate which contestants would get picked for each team. Below I've listed my best guesses and why. "Hero" is very open to interpretation, here's a couple examples of "Heroes" from Survivor; there was Cirie who was "an inspiration to couch potatoes everywhere" and Stephanie who, in her initial appearance, was on a team that lost every elimination challenge until she was the only one left. So, here are mine:
Duncan - Pretty obvious pick, they don't put kids in juvie without a good reason
Izzy - They also don't send the RCMP after kids without a good reason
Heather - need I explain?
Alejandro - Again, need I explain?
Scott - Again...
Gwen - if that'sevenher real name. Pretty much seen as a villain after the "boyfriend kisser" incident
Blaineley - Cheated at that eating competition
Lighting - The S4 finale cemented him as a jerk and tormentor of the weak.
Geoff - Got a disturbing amount of pleasure out of tormenting the other campers
Courtney - Supercedes the game rules by threateneing to call her lawyer
DJ - Most obvious pick
Trent - Nice guy/victim. As far as I know, the only member of an "official" couple to get dumped.
Ezekiel - Because he always gets voted off first
Harold - Committed "seppuku"
Lindsay - Sticking it to Heather in Season 1
Sadie - Went for weeks without her BFFFFFFFFFFFFF in Season 1, always came across as the gentler of the two.
Justin - Odd choice, but I'm thinking that he's a sort of "wounded angel" after losing his good looks then getting rejected by Courtney. Plus don't tell me you don't want to see him go toe-to-toe with Al?