Rhonda, a divorced mother, discourages her daughter Molly from going out with a man she just met, because "he´s a man." When Rhonda´s hate for men causes her death moments later, Othniel argues that Molly will be alone her entire life, unless Rhonda goes back and somehow makes Molly open to love again.
Rhonda agrees, but to her surprise, she comes back as the manager of a matchmaking company.
But Molly isn´t the only one who´s having problems with love - and Rhonda doesn´t even see that her friend, the baker Zeke is in love with her. Before he has the chance to tell her, Rhonda´s ex-husband (who left her 11 years ago) comes back - and proposes! Neither Zeke nor Molly can understand it when Rhonda says yes...
Finally, after a number of matchmaking attempts have failed, it´s a cake that changes everything.