Fed up with the all the killing by the Fifth Column radicals, Erica and others set out to capture the faction's leader, Eli. Jack volunteers to be Eli bait.
Anna heads to the Vatican to try and convince them that the Visitors aren't all bad. She has to use her powers to get them to come around. She finds out one of the cardinals is actually a Visitor sent to study the human soul and how it will fare if humans and Visitors breed.
Jack heads to upstate New York, where Eli lives, wearing a tracking device. He finds out that Eli preaches against the Visitors because they are responsible for his child's death. He and Jack come to an understanding.
Tyler, meanwhile, is angry with Jack and trashes his church with the help of his friends.