Three friends in college wants to play a bit with the class nerd, and the girl makes a pass at him. But when the nerd thinks that he´s going to get laid, instead he´s ridiculed. But when he makes resistance, they hold him down, and a unfortunate blow by a baseball bat kills him... The three friends decides to bury him. Ten years later the body is found, and Chapel makes it his business to find the culprits. He sends every classmate a baseball bat and studies their reaction. Soon the three friends have a reunion of their own. Then Chapel enters as Arnie, a naive stalker, that claims to have seen everything. But the three friends don't want their lives ruined by a numbskull and decides to kill Arnie. But is there really an Arnie?moreless
K.C.'s friend is impregnated by the married Senator Haywood. When Haywood rejects her, she flees and drives off the road. The senator does nothing to help and lets her die. K.C. and Chapel begin to set up the senator for payback.
A witness loses his motivation to testify against arms dealers when his wife is kidnapped. Chapel plans to put the claustrophobic arms dealer in a box to make him talk, but a zealous cop jails Chapel instead.
Pam Broder, the only witness to a murder, is threatened by the imprisoned killer through anonymous letters. After the killer Hix is set free, Chapel decides to help Ms. Broder. But Hix warns Chapel to stop following him.
A sheriff frames a young couple for drug dealing and shoots the husband. A deputy objects and is murdered. Chapel enters the picture and is forced to make a tough decision about his own client.
An FBI profiler hides evidence that could exonerate someone suspected of being a serial murderer. Mr. Chapel finds out and goes after the profiler. However, the profiler uses his professional skills to profile Chapel.
A secretary is murdered after uncovering the boss's money laundering operation. Her husband is contacted by a mysterious Mr. Chapel, who promises to bring the culprit to justice. Chapel is assisted by his former client, KC, who works at the DA's office.