When Max continues to fail at magic, Jerry hires him a Wizard tutor named Tutor. Justin suddenly has a crush on her and Alex becomes good friends with her, and they all start bonding. Justin asks Tutor out on a date at the Leprechaun Grill (which is just a small restaurant with workers dressed as leprechauns), while Alex and Tutor sneaking into movies. Soon, Alex and Justin find out that Tutor is going to leave when Max passes his exam, they purposely cause their little brother to fail just so Tutor will stay. Back at the Leprechaun Grill, Max confronts his siblings for what hey did. Even though he forgives them, he releases a grumpy leprechaun, that Alex was teasing earlier, who then attacks them.
In the end, before Tutor says goodbye, Alex and Justin learn that Tutor is a half-elf, in which elves have a magical quality that makes people love them, and that is why they both liked her.