As Eric and Heidi's marriage tries to get back on track, Jaye spirals wildly out of control as the muses convince her that she must "Save Him From Her", save him from the fact that someone is going to murder him. To deal with things, she visits the family's therapist.
Jaye performs an unethical act to her neighbor, proposed by the animals, of hiding her checks. She also continues to make her photo album of her neighbor "Fat Pat" grow. Ultimately, the awful acts improves the lives of a few of her neighbors.
An old celebrity, Millie Markus, drops into town to reminisce about being the first woman to ride in a barrel over the falls and survive. Only, she wasn't. Her friend, Vivian, the real one who went over the falls, calls her bluff.
When Jaye's brother sees her talking to inanimate objects, he begins to question her state of mind; the animals help Jaye reunite her family with the housekeeper who was deported thanks to Sharon. Meanwhile, while trying to get the maid back, Jaye finds herself in legal trouble.