I gave this a fairly high score because the first hour of the show was really good. We had a nice and stiff puroresu style match between CM Punk and William Regal, which despite being short, was really great and got a solid reaction from the crowd on the title switch. The 6 man mini-Rumble was fun as well, with a unique ending that truly built up Randy Orton as a contender. The contract signing also had excellent mic work by John Cena, HBK and JBL. And Santino Marella's hilarity continues, although he's starting to really act like Fez from That 70's Show.
After that things fell apart. The final segment with Vince's return was just really awkward and the beatdown got zero heat whatsoever. The women's match was brutal to watch as well.