Every year for Halloween, the upper school creates a haunted house for the lower school. Logan is in charge and sets out to make this the most terryfing house ever. Zoey thinks he has taken it too far when all of the children run out screaming after being in there for a few seconds. Meanwhile, Nicole chases a guy she thinks is her crush Tim, but is really Mark Del Figallo in the same mummy costume, which he can't pull off because Quinn used her special extra-strong glue. Michael waits outside for more things that Logan wants in the haunted house and gets chased by two french teachers who think he is injured because of his halloween costume. Back in the haunted house, Dustin's roomate Jack has gone missing and everyone starts to get afraid. Zoey blames it on Logan as he designed it. Logan is worried about what has gone wrong. Dustin tells them that before Jack disappeared they heard a voice calling his name. All of a sudden, a screen is on and Jack's face appears screaming for help. Then the voice calls Dustin's name, there is lightning and he's gone. Zoey is upset, and Chase tries to get out but finds the door locked. Soon after, the same voice starts calling Logan's name, and he starts screaming and tries to break the door down. Everyone starts screaming, Logan gets the door open, runs away, and then Chase turns on the light. Everyone starts laughing, and Dustin and Jack come out of a coffin beside the door.