Lights: On Off
On CBSSports.com: Watch March Madness® Online Now!
Thursday 9:00 PM on The CW

Episode Score

 
8.8 Great
976 votes

Your Score

Air Date

Thursday February 15, 2007

Production Code

3T5515

Episode Summary

The Winchester brothers seek the help of their family friend Bobby while investigating a series of unexplained happenings on a local college campus.

Read Full Recap » (warning: possible spoilers!)
  •  
    9 Superb

    The first Trickster episode! hide show

    I must admit that the Trickster is an awesome choice for a monster of the week: he's witty and saucy, stylish and biting, with a deadly sense of humor and smart-ass attitude that is really charming. Plus, its power is both subtle and awe-inspiring (bending and creating reality out of thin air), and it offers endless story possibilities.

    Richard Speight Jr. is unbelievably good as this demigod and it's perhaps safe to say that, thanks to him, the Trickster turned out to be one of the two really lovable monsters of this show (the other one being, at least in my opinion, the Shapeshifter of "Monster Movie", 4x05).

    "Tall Tales" has also the most hilarious scene of Season Two (the slow dance with the aliens on the notes of "The Lady in Red" by Chris De Burgh) and its storytelling technique (the alternate versions of Sam and Dean, and Bobby's constant recollection of the story) is both effective and brilliantly funny (the editing of this episode was really top-notch).

    Great performance by all the cast and professional direction by Bradford May. The script by John Shiban is really good, even if Jeremy Carver outdid it with the second Trickster episode, "Mystery Spot" (3x11).

    Do you agree?
     
    Report Abuse
  •  
    8.5 Great

    Another filler episode, but one that lays on the humor. hide show

    I've gotten used to the idea of Supernatural following big plot revealing episodes with some filler ones, and this one didn't seem to really do anything except bring some humor and hilarious Sam and Dean pranks.

    The episode, whether or not it was a filler, was certainly creative. It involved Sam and Dean telling the story of what happened on their hunt to Bobby. However, they both believe they've done something to each other's possessions, so their stories don't exactly match up. Watching Sam hug the frat guy and try to console him was hilarious, and watching Dean tell the story as if he were the most attractive man on Earth was even more priceless.

    The one thing I liked a lot about the episode was the inclusion of Bobby. If there's one character I can see sticking around with the Winchester brothers, it's definitely Bobby. He has the same amount, if not more, knowledge as Sam and Dean and seems to be an all around good character

    I'm hoping for the next episode to be a little better. Not that this one wasn't, it just felt a little too filler to me.

    Do you agree?
     
    Report Abuse
  •  
    10 Perfect

    This episode was hilarious. hide show

    This episode was hilarious especially with all the flashbacks, telling the story from the past. My favorite part is when Sam is acting gay "We have a special investigation here' That was hilarious. Sam's flashbacks sounded more realistic. I also like the part when Sam is helping the guy cope with the guy's abduction. That was another hilarious scene. looks like all the fighting they have been having was caused by the Trickster. When he turns out alive in the episode at the end, it is worth watching. Foreshadowing he might come back in the future er.. hurmph.. "Mystery Spot"... cough cough.

    Do you agree?
     
    Report Abuse
  •  
    8.7 Great

    The only MotW you gotta love! The Trickster's definitely got style. And our boys are cuter than ever. hide show

    The ultimate SPN guilty pleasure, great concept, tons of fun, and the cutest brotherly brawl EVER … oh and we got to see Bobby again, always a bonus.

    The Trickster lies uncontended on the top of my MotW top 10 list. The idea is very creative, as well as innately hilarious, can't imagine a more enjoyable monster than this guy, and he's got style. Chris De Burgh's "Lady in Red" and the song by Barry White were the last think I thought I'd hear on this show.

    The Winchesters have never looked so childishly adorable, it's unbelievable. The bickering was immensely funny, what was even better … the brotherly scuffle, I was LOLing so hard my stomach hurt! The only MotW I can honestly say I didn't want dead, and I'm really glad he's still out there … something tells me we might run into him again! xD

    Do you agree?
     
    Report Abuse
  •  
    10 Perfect

    This episode is amazingly funny! I've watched it so many times! hide show

    Sam and Dean call on fellow hunter Bobby for help with violent occurrences on a college campus, but Bobby has suspicions about both the culprit and the brothers' escalating feud, telling them to resolve it straight away. This episode is hilarious!!!! Dean, what so you think you're doing? I love it!!!! Sam looks so gay at that point! I feel for you. You're to precious for this world!!!! Love it! This episode was hilarious! Slow dancing aliens? Classic, classic, classic. We're are just like an old married couple, but they can get divorced, me and him, we're like siamese twins. conjoined twins..

    Do you agree?
     
    Report Abuse
 
See All Reviews

Episode Cast and Crew

View All
  • In the final scene when we see the alleged dead Trickster in the chair, as the scene starts, you can see Richard Speight's chest rise as he takes a deep breath and holds it. []
  • In the end, the bed and disco lights are still on the stage even though all the stuff that the trickster supposedly conjured up faded away when he was stabbed. This should have alerted Sam and Dean to the fact that the trickster was still alive, as seen at the end of episode. []
  • International Airdates:
    Denmark: March 11, 2007 on TV3
    Italy: August 19, 2008 on Rai2
    The Netherlands: March 15, 2009 on NET5
    New Zealand: May 8, 2009 on TV2 []
  • This episode received its own special article at weeklyworldnews.com. Oddly, the article explains one thing that goes unmentioned in the episode itself: the stakes used to kill a Trickster must be dipped in the blood of one of its victims. []
  • Music: Lady in Red by Chris DeBurgh, Walk Away by James Gang, Can't Get Enough of Your Love, Babe by Barry White, Next to You by JunkFood []
More Notes
  • Sam: There was this guy. He was a research scientist. Animal testing.
    Dean: Ya, you know, a dick. Which fits the pattern. []
  • Sam: How would you feel if I screwed with the Impala?
    Dean: It'd be the last thing you ever did. []
  • Sam: You know something? I've put up with a lot from you!
    Dean: What are you talking about? I'm a joy to be around! []
More Quotes
  • Dean: I don’t know, man. I think they’re called Purple Nurples.
    A Purple Nurple is a type of alcoholic cocktail drink that is made by putting coconut rum, triple sec, Blue Curacao, cranberry juice, and ice in a cocktail shaker. The ingredients are then shaken up and strained into a glass for serving. []
  • Chainsaw-Wielding Cannibal
    This character references Leatherface from The Texas Chain Saw Massacre series of films from 1974, starring Gunnar Hansen. []
  • Dean: This is my shuttle co-pilot, Major Tom.
    Referencing to the main character of two famous David Bowie songs. For the first time, Major Tom appears in the 1969 hit Space Oddity, on the album of the same name ("Ground Control to Major Tom..."). In 1980, Major Tom returns in the song Ashes to Ashes, on the album Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) ("Do you remember a guy that's been in such an early song? I've heard a rumor from Ground Control..."). []
More Allusions
advertisement

Top Contributors

What is a TV.com Contributor?