Most Controversial episode
hide
show
Home
-Creepy freakin' teaser.
-Was this before or after Slipknot released their first CD?
-Mulder loves baseball. This episode makes a creepy connection to the American pass-time.
-Every little town has a dark secret.
-Yikes! Creepy eyes under the bed!
-I love the shot of the Sheriff contemplating pulling out his gun from storage before ultimately putting it back. It shows how much he wants to believe that his town is still safe.
-"One good, last look around…" True.
-Wonderful Wonderful. This is a great application of situational irony exemplified by music.
-Who would win in a fight, the Peacock Brothers or Chuck Norris? I think they would give Chazz a run for his money.
-This episode is exceptionally well directed. The close-up shots and the expertly executed camera-pans are fantastic.
-There is not very much of a score by Mark Snow in this episode.
-"They really went Cave Man on them." Mulder's comment is more comedic because the Peacocks look like the Geico cave men.
-The Gang-bang scene haunted my dreams for months when I fist saw this.
-"Bah ram ewe." Perfect time for a little comic relief.
-"The War of Northern Aggression." Not just inbreeds, but southern inbreeds.
-Got to love the trunk space in those early model Cadillacs.
-Another X Files episode where the monster/villain gets away in the end.
What can I say about this episode that has not already been said? It is fantastic. This story really pushed the envelope of what can be shown on network TV. Even while re-watching it today--I was wincing. The thought of Mrs. Peacock hiding under my bed gave me nightmares well into December. The murder of the Sheriff and his wife is particularly disturbing as well. I will never (and I suspect that I am not alone on this) be able to listen to Johnny Mathis the same way again. This is probably one of the best-known episodes of the show's entire run. It seems like about once a week someone will come onto the board to ask 'what episode is the one with the mutant family that kills a baby?' There is a certain lack of original score in this episode that maintaining the constant malevolent, dreary feeling. This differs from many other X Files episodes that normally feature the ear pleasing tones of Mr. Mark Snow.
I noticed something about this episode that I had not noticed in prior viewings. There is a sort of a non-spoken, sympathetic connection between the Peacocks and the Sherriff. Both families were afraid of change. They were both entrenched in their traditions and way of life. Each group was also content coexisting apart from each other. The scene where Mulder asks if they could inspect the fetal cadaver in the Sheriff's office with the door locked. He replies, "Oh, everyone knows that I never have my door locked." (Or something like that.)
I am not sure if this episode speaks more toward anti-big business or anti-government. Either way, they both are recurring themes in the X Files universe. The Peacocks were anti-progress and anti-technology. Additionally, the Sheriff seemed to be anti-progress. He seemed happy to let things lie and was reluctant, to say the least, about involving the FBI in the case. He was, to his credit, much nicer than the local small town law enforcement usually is to Mulder and Scully (a la DPO or Quagmire.)
Overall, this is an excellent episode. Part of the appeal for me is that I am sort of a closet gore-hound, not so much the new age torture-porn of SAW and Hostel but classic gore like Hellraiser, Cannibal Holocaust, and Braindead. This episode could have been a great addition to the midnight grind-house classics if it were a movie in the late 1970s.
10/10
I feel sort of anti human by giving this grotesque episode such a high rating. Nevertheless, I think it deserves the style points. Groundbreaking television.