madison
advertisement
2ratchet
Level
1
rank: Weatherman
profile views: 46
forum posts: 6
member since: Feb 21, 2006
see all »

my feed

2ratchet: Profile

RECENT SHOW UPDATES

RECENT ACTOR UPDATES

RECENT FRIENDS' REVIEWS

  • 8.5
    loading_img
    member since: 11/23/05

    The Bottom Line: "Great"

    After a very disappointing season 6, the writers decided to re-think what they wanted to do with the next season. They promised us that they would try to do something different with the story.

    Due to the long break between seasons, the writers also decided to give us something extra between seasons, which would help to set up the story that they would tell in season 7, basically like a longer version of the DVD extra that they've had in the past, where it showed specific key moments that would lead up to the following season. And that's really how this movie should be approached.

    It did have its own main story, where Jack ended up in Africa, helping a guy named Mr. Benton with a school that he set up there. Coincidentally, at the same time Jack is about to leave the school, there's trouble in Africa, where a group of men have started raising an army of children in order to start a coup in Africa.

    The movie moves very slowly at the start, and the first half hour was a bit shaky. I did like the idea of the coup, and it had a very nice opening scene where they showed one of the kids in the army being pursuaded to kill somebody, which I thought was a very creepy scene. After that, it shifts to Jack, and develops his relationship with the kids, as well as his reluctance to go back to the US. I thought that this was fitting for Jack's character, after what happened with Audrey in season 6, and had a few nice moments for Jack, seeing him in this new light, but I think that they could have done a better job at pacing to keep it interesting. Also, some of the scenes where the people were recruiting for the coup could have been written better, because I feel like the writers were going for a much more dramatic feeling, but some of the writing seemed off, and it ended up cheapening those scenes.

    However, once the coup story started to connect with Jack's story with the kids at the school, it started to take off from there. The movie did have a lot less action than some of the episodes on the show, but I think that that was actually a good thing. It helped to show Jack as a kind of guardian for the kids, making him seem more human, as opposed to the super human hero he sometimes seems like in the show. There was, however, enough action to keep viewers interested, and move the story along. And the action that was there, was very good.

    This main story, with the Africans, and the group of people that were starting the coup, I feel was a nice change of pace from what we got from previous seasons. It was not an attack on LA, or the US for that matter. It was strictly an issue dealing with Africa that Jack happened to get involved with. It wasn't perfect though. It had its rough parts, and some parts were very predictable, but overall, it was just a nice change of pace. And if it was just this part of the story, I'd be very excited about season 7 despite the problems that it had.

    However, with the work that was put into coming up with an interesting, new kind of problem that wasn't like anything in the past, they had to ruin it with a side-story that we've probably seen in every season so far. Basically, there's a conspiracy involving this one company, which also connects to the white house. The company is helping to support the coup in Africa, and they also have the help of one of the limo drivers (of all people they could have chosen to be involve, why pick a limo driver?). I really did not care for that story in the movie. One of the main problems that I had with it was the person who almost discovered the conspiracy, Chris. Chris' character was just annoying and pointless. He realizes what's going on, but his friend (the new president's son) doesn't believe him because he's a drug addict, and needs proof in order to take action. I can understand needing proof about the conspiracy, but the drug addiction was completely pointless, and didn't add anything to the story. I guess that I'll have to see where they are going to take this part of the story in season 7 before making up my mind about it though, because they didn't really do much with it in the movie.

    On the other hand, there was a small story with the new president. It showed President Daniels leaving the White House, after making one last decision that will probably end up affecting the story in season 7. Basically, he cuts off all support to Africa, leaving them to deal with their own problems. And of course, they have the new president come in and weigh in her opinion on the subject, showing the differences between the two characters. This part of the story wasn't really fleshed out within the movie, just giving you a taste for who the new president is, and showing the difference between her and Daniels. But despite this, I thought it was a pretty good way to introduce her, and was much more interesting than the conspiracy story. It wasn't great, but not bad either.

    Overall, this might not be the best of 24. Its stories weren't really fleshed out, even with Jack's story. It only gave you a taste of what's to come. But that was the point of the movie. It was ment to be like the DVD specials that do just that, and in that case, it did do a great job, despite having a few moments that weren't that great. It's too early to say that 24 is back or not, but based on this movie, it does have a promising future.

    11/24/2008 6:45am | report abuse
  • 5.0
    loading_img
    member since: 11/23/05

    The Bottom Line: "Mediocre"

    Four and a half years ago, the Atlantis team came through the stargate in order to find the lost city of Atlantis, which may have caused more harm than good as this episode points out. Now Colonel Sheppard's team is put on trial against the people of Atlantis, and if they lose they'll be sent to a planet which is cut off from the stargate system.

    There are several things about this episode that I didn't like. First of all, while this isn't the first clip show in the Stargate universe, it is the first one that was on Atlantis. I for one was happy that they had gone so long without being reduced to do a clip show, so that they could come up with their own stories instead of come up with a new way to show us what we already know. And then there's the fact that this story, of the heroes of the show being put on trial for crimes that they've committed throughout the show, is one of the most annoying cliches of television. It's been used so many times before that anybody who watches sci-fi should know at least one episode with that plot. However, in this case it wasn't nearly as annoying as most episodes with this kind of plot. This is because, while I do like the show and its characters, they really aren't guiltless, and these charges aren't completely bogus like most of the charges in these kinds of episodes. Whether it was through an accident caused by something understandable (waking up the entire Wraith species by killing the queen Wraith in the series premier), a bad decision (creating Michael, and activating the code for the replicators to attack the Wraith which ended up causing the replicators to attack humans), these charges really were understandable, and I would have liked to have seen a response to the charges. But what do we get as a response? "You have got to be kidding me!" This would be a good response in a normal trial episode, with bogus charges, but in an episode where the charges are as understandable as these, I'd hope for something more.

    However, this episode wasn't a complete waste of time. First of all, it greatly strengthened Woolsey's character as a negotiator and manipulator of situations. While Woolsey has had a few decent moments before now, he hasn't really showed his worth as the head of command. Hopefully this will be further developed in the future, so that he will become a more valuable member of the cast of characters.

    Another good thing about this episode is that it sets up the coalition of species, the people who charge Atlantis of the crimes, as well as a few of the behind-the-scenes politics of it. It turned out that the Genii were the ones who put the coalition up to the trial, because they were trying to gain power in the coalition, and they didn't want Atlantis to challenge that power. However, Woolsey finds out, and manages to escape the charges by showing the coalition that Atlantis would be much better allies than the Genii. This could play a much bigger role in the rest of the season, leading up to the series finale.

    Overall, however, the bad outweighs the good in this episode, and this is probably the weakest episode of the series.

    10/31/2008 6:38am | report abuse
  • 9.5
    loading_img
    member since: 11/23/05

    The Bottom Line: "Superb"

    This episode is one that will always stand out to me as one of the most unique, and most brilliant episodes of the series. It's based on the simple idea of having somebody interview the characters we know from the the series, and have them talk about their personal thoughts and experiences in the war.

    The producers of the show decided to have the actors ad-lib most of the responses in the episode according to what their characters would say. And in doing this, we get to see a new side to the different characters, with a much more intimate feeling than any other episode.

    The questions deal with the war, what it is like being away from home, how their experiences have changed them, and a few other questions along those lines. Some of the answers add a certain amount of humor which is much more subtle than most of the other episodes, and some of the answers and a subtle sense of drama. In fact, one of the answers given by Father Mulcayhy about how his experiences have changed him (one of the only scripted responses in the episode) is also possibly the most haunting lines in the whole series.

    Overall, this was a great episode, that did so much with so little, and added a lot to the characters that we know and love.

    10/22/2008 6:39pm | report abuse

RECENT FRIENDS' BLOGS

  • member since: 08/27/05

    5 More Winning Entries

    This will be very short blog today because i have alot going on in personal life most of it not good and I will be starting on things that need to be done for the GGBU that will be for tommorrow. Now For the good news i have 5 more banners that have been accepted in the win column bringing my total up to 17 since i have been designing. Befor getting to the winning banners congrats to all who had their banners acepted. Now for the new winners:

    1. Postal 3

    2. Monopoly

    3. Naruto: The Broken Bond

    4. Highlander

    5. Go Sports Skydiving

    Until next time....

    Posted 12/04/2008 2:05pm | views: 16,083
  • member since: 08/27/05

    Currently Reading: The Bible!?

    I know, shocking.

    Despite having been of the Christian faith, at one point, I've never actually sat down and read the thing on my own. So I decided to get myself a copy of the NIV. For like $13, it's really nice. Nicely bound, large font, and all that. Quite large, though. Larger than I remember it being, anyway. The only problem is that I'm not really sure where to start reading it. I read a bit of Genesis and Leviticus, although, my Statistics teacher recommend going to John first. Any advice here would be nice.

    I liked what I read of Genesis. There was one main thing that I didn't like in Leviticus (from what I've read). That being it's stance on homosexuality, although, I don't think I'll ever agree with the Bible on this (for obvious reasons).

    I do want to read the entire thing through. But, seeing as it's like 1400+ pages, I don't think I'll be accomplishing that any time soon.

    Posted 12/03/2008 8:17pm | views: 16,083
  • member since: 08/27/05

    I'm losing my like for this site

    I'm seriously losing my liking for this site.  Not as fun as it used to be.  I havn't posted on forums in about a year. Nothing interesting. Ever since I've gotton myself a girlfriend, I've lost my likeing for this site. Its the same crap almost all the time.

     Theres always one person that is like "I'm Back!", you know who I'm talking about, and you were like "Who is this person?" . Then theres the person thats posting something from a article. THen theres the person that posts what they're getting this week.idk.its just all the same.I'll still be on here.just  less.oh and no one reads my blogs. or just no one comments them.

    Posted 11/30/2008 6:19pm | views: 16,083
advertisement