CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | MP3.com | TV.com | Metacritic

The fine line between hack and genius

At one time, my lifelong goal was to write screenplays for Hollywood. Maybe that was just an excuse to watch so many movies and television shows, but I applied myself with the diligence and fervor of the newly-converted. I tracked down Campbell's "Faces of the Hero", a writer's guide to archetypes in storytelling. I read a library full of fiction, and some non-fiction. I've watched many hours of television, both live and on DVD. I've revisited classics like "Kung Fu" and struggled with the over-acting in "Renegade".

As I was watching "Threshold" the other night, I noticed they were introducing a minor mystery about one of the secondary characters... not a big mystery, but enough for me to take note of it. It got me thinking about "Lost" and how the main attraction of that show was the mysteries... what their character's backgrounds were, what the deal was on the island, was it natural or supernatural? And I realized how difficult it is to walk that fine line...

Tell the audience too little about a character, to try and foster a great deal of mystery, and they become uninteresting and unsympathetic. The marine on "Threshold" missed running to someone's deathbed because he was on a mission. I realized I didn't really care, because I didn't know who it was, couldn't sympathize with him, because the only thing I knew about him was his ability to bark orders and shoot a gun.

But the sword has a second edge... tell the audience too much about a character, and the questions are gone. They have no reason to tune in/read further because their questions have been answered. How interesting will "Reunion" be once we know who of the six friends was murdered? How easy will it be to deduce who killed them with the limited number of motives available to incite their death?

It's a fine line, and the good writers must walk it like a tightrope balanced between a swamp full of crocodiles and a pool of sharks. It makes me question my own equilibrium as a writer, because I've seen and felt audience reaction when it's all gone wrong. I may not ever write a blockbuster movie, or the great American novel, but I'm still fascinated by their intricacies.

To that end, I'd like to ask you all... What mysteries intrigued you about a show? What answered questions made you stop watching?
Posted by Diela, 10/08/2005 11:14am  2 Comments
Print    Email    Tag    Digg this

Still in Houston...

We're still hanging out here, waiting. Hubby may have also picked up an actual JOB instead of going with the self-employed thing. His former business partner was taken in by their former employer's Houston office, and hubby may be going along with that plan. Really, if I could name names without invading anyone's privacy, that last sentence would make sense.

Anyway, our only worry is daughter's schooling. I've been holding out for so long, which is odd because I *hated* her former school's mismanagement of funding, but this school would ABSOLUTELY require putting her on a bus, which she's never done, and I'm not confident she can handle. She's a very tiny thing, and that's not just mom-fear talking. The kids in her class last year used to try and carry her around like a doll. Sigh.

Anyway, I wanted to give out a semi-public THANK YOU to my friends here who sent me goodies to help me get through this stressful post-Katrina time. You know who ya are.
Posted by Diela, 10/01/2005 11:04pm  2 Comments
Print    Email    Tag    Digg this

Serenity NOW!

The day has arrived. Joss Whedon's film that thousands of us rabid "Firefly" fans have been dying to see opened today. Due to some budgetary constraints, I will not get to see every single showing of it today, but I AM going to a 7:30 showing. Hopefully. A part of me is wishing I show up and the show is sold out IF my printer had made it in our transition after the hurricane, I would have bought the tickets yesterday on FANDANGO and been done with it. Ah well.

Anyhoo, I implore anyone with enough cash to scrape together to run down and buy a ticket now. You don't even have to watch it if you don't want to (BUT WHY would you NOT???)

And may the reavers never visit you while you're sleeping
Posted by Diela, 09/30/2005 4:28pm  2 Comments
Print    Email    Tag    Digg this

Kiss my butt, Rita

Okay, this is getting ridiculous. Am I going to end up a refugee from my refuge?

We're loading up on water and canned food to ride out Rita, but we're watching the map and thinking it might be a good time to fly up to MN for the weekend.

Or maybe it'll still hook north and blow over our god-awful carport
Posted by Diela, 09/22/2005 9:32am  4 Comments
Print    Email    Tag    Digg this

(Wo)Man of Science, (Wo)man of faith

Let me add a little preface here about this blog; while this is not about "Lost" the show, there will probably be several references to it which may confuse anyone who has not watched the show and/or posted to the message board about it here.

A lot has happened over the last few weeks that has brought the division between faith and science into sharp focus for me. I don't have any faith anymore, and probably haven't for a very long time. I'd say when I managed a home-electronics store in Chicago in the early '90s is probably when it happened. I had so many people ripping me off, it wasn't even funny.

My lack of faith... in people, gods, the great force of the universe, what have you... is probably why I identify with the character of Jack much more readily than Locke (both from LOST for the uninitiated). While both men seem a bit imbalanced in their approaches, I can usually see where Jack is coming from, while Locke remains a mystery, or worse, appears to have gone looney-tunes.

Even now, post-Katrina, where most everyone has been very kind and helpful, it has not restored my faith. I see huge fundraisers and telethons going on, supposedly for my benefit. I smirk and wonder how much of it would actually make its way to me if we were actually seeking help (hubby is stubbornly proud) and how much of that money is actually going to benefit opportunistic businesses and the managers of these events. One Wal-Mart employee told me that they're not offering discounts at their store (this was one with a grocery in it that's very close to our new apartment) because the Corporate office has already donated a million dollars. Okay, I can accept that... I guess. Donated to whom? For what purpose? I can tell you, I need groceries *today*. I'm not going to need money to rebuild until tomorrow, if then. That's the "science" part of my nature... the pragmatist.

It's great that people are giving, and giving generously... but when will we get what they gave? Six months from now when the bureaucracy has finally finished with it? I probably won't need it then. Give us tax breaks, price breaks, whatever, but not promises. Because if the Red Cross is anything like the Army, they're spending most of that money on moving people around, and wasting half of it on food people don't eat. I'd like to see the garbage the shelters are producing, just to see how much waste is taking place. And if donations are going to help "rebuild" New Orleans, good luck... because I swear if I see one single repair to a government building before housing is rebuilt, I will go ballistic.
Posted by Diela, 09/18/2005 7:58am  4 Comments
Print    Email    Tag    Digg this

My Recent Reviews

 
7.0 Good
The 4400
Life Interrupted
Avg Score: 8.84    Total Ratings: 536    Total Reviews: 48
Users who agree: 1    Users who disagree: 4
Can you say Deus Ex Machina? While I'm happy our main investigator finally has a decent love-interest, why do I feel like the writers have pulled a fast one on us over and over this "second" season.

Maybe it's because the first season was written as a mini-series event and not expected to continue on as a recurring series, but the rapid-fire changes prevalent in these first episodes of season two seem like plotline-tweaking by the writers to create something that will last through seven seasons. Let's look at the changes thus far in the season.

-Lily, Richard, and child are no longer on the run.
-Collier is suddenly kind and benevolent. "The baby made me see the error of my ways" indeed.
-Sean is suddenly in charge of the 4400 foundation.
-New wife in the picture for Tom.

I've never felt so hoodwinked since "Buffy" introduced a sister out of nowhere. I expected better. Bah.
Report Abuse Posted Jul 20, 2005
7.0 Good
Law & Order: Criminal Intent
Faith
Avg Score: 9.01    Total Ratings: 66    Total Reviews: 3
Users who agree: 2   
Sometimes I think the new American dream is all about finding ways to get people to give you money without having to earn it.

In this episode our two detectives stumble onto a confidence scheme while investigating a murderer. Though the introductory portion is confusing, it does all sort out at the end. It did seem hard to stick with at first, because the method of the crime didn't make it readily apparent exactly *who* had been murdered. Then you spend several minutes trying to figure out who those five people were at the introductory segment, because you don't see them again for quite a few minutes into the episode.

The ending was quite moving though... it's sad how someone can deceive themselves so thouroughly that they believe murder in whatever cause is okay. An okay episode, but it could have used a dose of clarity.
Report Abuse Posted Jul 15, 2005
7.8 Good
CSI
Big Middle
Avg Score: 8.40    Total Ratings: 199    Total Reviews: 6
Prejudice occurs much more frequently than one might think, and CSI seems to spotlight it frequently. Whether it's ageism, sexism, or weightism (?) CSI seems to show sensitivity to all groups. This episode didn't seem to handle it as adroitly as other discrimination types, but they did try.

This episode was up to usual CSI standards with regards to pacing, revelation of the mystery, and subject matter. I felt they could have gone more in-depth on the Overweight convention characters (and why every "deviant" group seems to be attracted to Grissom) but otherwise it was an excellent episode.

I sometimes feel that Warrick's gambling addiction only came about so that they'd have a "gambling expert" on the team... they need to develop that more. And I love Sarah's sensitivity at the DNA sampling.

Great episode; could have been better, but I've seen far worse.


Report Abuse Posted Jul 15, 2005
8.6 Great
The Dead Zone
Still Life
Avg Score: 8.26    Total Ratings: 101    Total Reviews: 5
When Johnny receives a painting from a mysterious source, he has a vision of the subject of the canvas being murdered.

This was an excellent episode, one that didn't touch on any of the series-long story arcs, but was self-contained and accessable to anyone watching the series for the first time.

There were a few plot twists, but they were paced well and not obviously foreshadowed. Patrick Bauchau did excellent work here, and I found his character far more appealing than his recent work on Carnivale. It's good to see they're using Bruce as a character more this season. Genevieve Cortese did an excellent job... her distaste of the art dealer's advances was palpable and well-played.

As an episode to introduce someone to the series, this would be an excellent third or fourth episode.
Report Abuse Posted Jul 11, 2005
9.7 Superb
The 4400
As Fate Would Have It
Avg Score: 9.12    Total Ratings: 418    Total Reviews: 16
Users who agree: 6   
This episode had examples of all the tiny things that come together to make this show one of the best ones I watch, but it was also an episode that seemed to take all the characters and make them appear to actually be the opposite of what we thought they were all along.

Is he really the bad guy? Is she really a liar? Did he know all along or did he only just find out? Forget what you thought you knew about the 4400... it's changed. Some of it was gradual, we may have suspected... but we didn't really know until now. And we still don't know if their motives are good... or just plain wrong.

I don't like to post spoilers in the reviews, and I try not to, so I'm definitely being vague on this one. So much happens in this episode that all I can say is make sure you watch this one. It's fascinating.
Report Abuse Posted Jul 10, 2005

Profile

 
Diela
Last online Sep 6, 2008 6:43 am PT
Member since Jun 21, 2004
Profile views: 220 (+ 1 new)
If you can see this, your browser does not support flash.
Space Cadet - More than 10 favorite shows, at least 20% of them sci-fi.  Drama King - More than 10 favorite shows, at least 20% dramas. Swashbuckler - More than 10 favorite shows, at least 20% of them action/adventure.  Ginsu Knife Contributite - This user has made at least 1 contribution.
My Other Profiles:
GameSpot MP3.com MovieTome
Send Message
Report Abuse

Stats

 
Level: 15    Completion: 15.93%
Rank: Ginsu Knife
Forum Posts: 378
Submissions
Accepted: 5
Pending: 0
Denied: 1
Total: 6
Reviews
Shows: 1
Episodes: 8
People: 0
Total: 9
Diela's Shows Breakdown:
Show Genre Breakdown
Science-Fiction 25: 36.8%
Drama 18: 26.5%
Action/Adventure 15: 22.1%
Comedy 5: 7.4%
Other 5: 7.4%

About Me

 
Diela
Stay at home mom with many hobbies.

Friends' Videos

 
The Calming Waves

taken at last year's beach holiday

Oct 7, 2006 by booksnbeach4me  |  368 Views

My RSS